After a major earthquake, a person wildly overestimates the probability of another earthquake occurring in the next month, despite actuarial data showing low likelihood. This most likely reflects the operation of:
- ABase rate neglect, because the person ignores the statistical frequency of earthquakes in the region
- BThe availability heuristic, because the vivid recent event comes to mind easilyCorrect
- CHindsight bias, because the person now believes the first earthquake was predictable beforehand
- DThe representativeness heuristic, because the earthquake fits the prototype of a natural disaster
Why B is right
The availability heuristic involves estimating the probability of an event based on how easily examples come to mind. Because the recent earthquake is vivid, emotionally charged, and easily recalled, it is cognitively available and leads to overestimating future earthquake probability. Kahneman and Tversky showed that availability-based estimates are systematically biased by recency, vividness, and emotional salience.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Base rate neglect refers to ignoring statistical frequency in favor of specific case information (like a witness description); here the issue is that vivid recent experience inflates estimates, which is availability.
- C
- Hindsight bias involves believing after an event that one could have predicted it ('I knew it all along'); the person here is making a future probability judgment, not revising their past predictive confidence.
- D
- The representativeness heuristic involves judging category membership based on similarity to a prototype; the person is estimating probability, but the driver is cognitive availability (recent vivid memory), not prototype matching.