Identical twins raised in different countries, speaking different languages, are found to show similar levels of extraversion. Which research conclusion does this finding MOST directly support?
- AThe environment has no influence on extraversion because identical twins always show the same personality regardless of upbringing
- BExtraversion has a substantial heritable component, since the twins are genetically identical and still similar despite different environmentsCorrect
- CLearning and social environment are the primary determinants of personality because both twins learned social behavior from their respective cultures
- DThe specific language spoken determines personality, since people who share personality also tend to share languages across cultures
Why B is right
When identical (MZ) twins raised in different environments show similar traits, this is strong evidence for genetic contributions to those traits. Because the twins share 100% of their DNA but had different environmental experiences (different countries, languages, cultures), their similarity on extraversion cannot be explained by shared environment — it must reflect genetic influence. This is the key logic behind the power of MZ-raised-apart studies for establishing heritability.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because this overstates the genetic conclusion; the finding supports genetic contribution, not the idea that environment has NO influence; even in such studies, the correlation between MZ twins is high but not perfect (1.0), leaving room for environmental effects.
- C
- Incorrect because this is directly contradicted by the finding; if twins raised in different environments with different cultures show similar extraversion levels, environment and social learning cannot be the PRIMARY determinant — genetics must play a significant role.
- D
- Incorrect because language spoken is not a determinant of personality; the finding about similar extraversion across different language environments actually argues AGAINST language/environment as a primary cause of personality similarities.
A person shows personality traits and coping styles remarkably similar to those they exhibited in childhood, even after major life changes. This is best described by which developmental concept?
- ACritical periods, where traits are permanently fixed during specific windows
- BContinuity, where development is gradual and traits persist across timeCorrect
- CDiscontinuity, where development proceeds in qualitatively distinct stages
- DPlasticity, where development is shaped by ongoing experience throughout life
Why B is right
Continuity in development refers to the gradual, quantitative nature of change and the tendency for early characteristics to persist over time. Evidence of long-term personality stability across situations and life phases is cited as evidence for continuity in developmental trajectories.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because critical periods are specific windows during which particular experiences have maximal impact; the described scenario is about long-term trait stability across life, which is better characterized as continuity.
- C
- Incorrect because discontinuity describes development that proceeds in qualitatively distinct stages, like Piaget's cognitive stages; the persistence of traits is evidence of continuity, not stage-like discontinuity.
- D
- Incorrect because plasticity emphasizes that development can be reshaped by ongoing experience; high plasticity would predict that major life changes would alter traits, the opposite of what is described.