Skip to content
AP Psychology · Social Psychology and Personality

Overjustification effect

Overjustification effect appears in 3 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Social Psychology and Personality. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

The overjustification effect happens when an outside reward for something you already enjoy lowers your interest in it. You start to think you do it for the reward, so when the reward stops, you lose motivation.

Why it matters

It shows that rewards can backfire. In a 1973 study by Mark Lepper and colleagues, preschoolers who were promised a certificate for drawing later drew less in free time than children who got no reward.

How the exam tests it

A typical stem describes someone who loved an activity, then got paid or won prizes for it, then lost interest once the prizes ended. You must name the overjustification effect: an extrinsic reward undermined intrinsic motivation.

Don’t confuse it with

This is not simple extinction from operant conditioning. Extinction is a behavior fading after rewards stop, while overjustification means interest falls below where it was before any reward began.

Overjustification effect in real questions

Example 1Medium
When a student who initially enjoys creative writing for its own sake begins receiving cash prizes for their stories, they later show less interest in writing when prizes are withdrawn. This demonstrates:
  1. AThe Yerkes-Dodson effect, where excessive incentives move arousal beyond the optimal level
  2. BThe overjustification effect, where external rewards undermine prior intrinsic motivationCorrect
  3. CLearned helplessness, where the removal of control over outcomes reduces motivation
  4. DExtinction, where a behavior decreases when its reinforcer is removed

Why B is right

The overjustification effect (Deci & Lepper) occurs when external rewards are provided for an already intrinsically motivating activity. The person comes to attribute their behavior to the external reward rather than their genuine interest, so when the reward is removed, the behavior becomes less attractive. This is a key concept in self-determination theory's cognitive evaluation framework.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the Yerkes-Dodson law describes how performance depends on arousal level (moderate arousal is optimal); the scenario concerns reduced interest after rewards are withdrawn, not performance impaired by over-arousal.
C
Incorrect because learned helplessness involves giving up after repeated uncontrollable failures; the student has not experienced uncontrollable failures but rather has had their intrinsic motivation undermined by external rewards.
D
Incorrect because extinction in operant conditioning occurs when a reinforcer is removed from a previously reinforced behavior; while reward withdrawal is involved, the student's reduced interest in writing reflects undermined intrinsic motivation, not simple operant extinction — the writing was not initially maintained by the prizes.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Social Psychology and Personality.