In a study on sleep deprivation and reaction time, participants complete a reaction time test after 8 hours of sleep, then again after 24 hours without sleep. Which design is this, and what is the primary concern?
- ALongitudinal design; the primary concern is attrition, as participants may drop out over the extended time period
- BBetween-subjects design; the primary concern is that the two groups may differ in initial reaction time
- CWithin-subjects design; the primary concern is order effects, as being tested twice may affect performanceCorrect
- DCross-sectional design; the primary concern is cohort differences between participants tested at different times
Why C is right
A within-subjects (repeated measures) design uses the same participants in all conditions. This controls for individual differences but introduces order effects: participants may perform differently on the second test due to practice (improving performance) or fatigue/carryover (worsening performance), independent of the sleep manipulation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because a longitudinal design tracks participants over months or years; this study measures the same participants across two conditions in a shorter timeframe, which is within-subjects.
- B
- Incorrect because a between-subjects design uses different participants for each condition; here the same participants complete both conditions, making it within-subjects.
- D
- Incorrect because a cross-sectional design compares different age groups at one point in time; this study uses the same participants across two conditions.