A researcher studying avoidance learning in rats finds that once a rat has learned to avoid a shock by jumping over a barrier when a warning light comes on, the avoidance behavior is extremely resistant to extinction — even when the shock apparatus is disconnected and no shocks are ever delivered. What is the most likely explanation for why avoidance is so resistant to extinction?
- AThe avoidance behavior is maintained by negative reinforcement: escaping the warning light (a conditioned fear stimulus) removes fear, so the rat never learns the shock is goneCorrect
- BThe rats develop a fixed action pattern during avoidance training that becomes biologically irreversible once established through operant conditioning
- CThe warning light has become a CS for pain through classical conditioning, and the CR (fear) is independently maintained by the light alone, even long after the shock has been removed
- DSpontaneous recovery of the avoidance response occurs indefinitely after extinction attempts, recreating the behavior regardless of the shock contingency
Why A is right
Avoidance behavior is maintained by negative reinforcement — the avoidance response removes the conditioned fear stimulus (the warning light, which through classical conditioning elicits fear). By jumping the barrier, the rat escapes the fear-arousing warning light and feels relieved. This relief (removal of conditioned fear) reinforces the avoidance. Critically, because the rat always jumps when the light comes on, it never stays long enough to discover that shocks no longer occur, so the avoidance behavior persists indefinitely. This two-factor theory (Mowrer) explains the paradoxical persistence of avoidance.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because fixed action patterns are genetically programmed behavioral sequences in ethology, not trained operant behaviors. Operant behaviors are not biologically irreversible; they can be modified. The avoidance persists due to its operant maintenance through negative reinforcement.
- C
- Incorrect because while the warning light does become a CS for fear (classical conditioning), the classical conditioning alone does not explain why the operant avoidance behavior persists. The fear CR would extinguish if the rat were exposed to the light without shock — but the avoidance prevents this exposure. The two-factor account (classical conditioning + operant negative reinforcement) is necessary.
- D
- Incorrect because spontaneous recovery is temporary and diminishes with each successive extinction test. Spontaneous recovery does not recreate behavior indefinitely — it produces temporary, weakened responses that should extinguish with additional trials. The permanent-seeming persistence of avoidance is explained by the negative reinforcement mechanism.