Patients with a rare neurological disorder are difficult to study through large-scale experiments. A researcher decides to conduct an in-depth investigation of one patient over several years, including neurological imaging, behavioral assessments, and clinical interviews. What is the PRIMARY weakness of this approach?
- AThe researcher cannot use statistical analysis because only one participant's data are collected
- BThe findings cannot be generalized to other patients with the disorder, limiting external validityCorrect
- CThe study lacks internal validity because there is no control group to compare the patient against
- DInformed consent cannot be obtained from a patient with a neurological disorder
Why B is right
The primary weakness of case studies is limited generalizability (external validity). Because the findings come from a single individual who may be atypical even within the group being studied, conclusions drawn about one person may not apply to others with the same disorder.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because statistical analysis can be applied to single-subject data (e.g., time-series analysis); moreover, the primary weakness is not about statistical methods but about generalizability.
- C
- Incorrect because internal validity concerns whether an IV caused the DV; case studies are typically descriptive and do not claim to establish cause-effect, making internal validity a less central concern than generalizability.
- D
- Incorrect because neurological disorders do not automatically preclude informed consent; the question also asks about research method weaknesses, not patient capacity.