Skip to content
AP Psychology · Biological Bases of Behavior

Experimental validity

Experimental validity appears in 3 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Biological Bases of Behavior. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Experimental validity is whether a study's design lets you trust its conclusion. Threats such as demand characteristics, placebo effects and experimenter bias undermine internal validity, which is whether the independent variable really caused the result. Each threat offers another explanation for the change you see.

Why it matters

In a sleep-deprivation study or a drug trial, a change in reaction time only counts if the design rules out other explanations. That is why drug trials use placebos and double-blind procedures, so neither participants' nor researchers' expectations shape the results.

How the exam tests it

A study scenario lists several problems, and you must name the one that fits. For example, sleep-deprived participants who guess the hypothesis and slow down on purpose show demand characteristics.

Don’t confuse it with

Demand characteristics are often confused with experimenter bias, but demand characteristics come from participants guessing the hypothesis, while experimenter bias comes from the researcher's expectations.

Experimental validity in real questions

Example 1Medium
Researchers are conducting a hypothetical experiment to test whether one night of sleep deprivation slows reaction time. Which of the following events during the study would BEST illustrate the problem of demand characteristics?
  1. ASleep-deprived participants given a decaffeinated drink they believe is caffeinated report feeling more alert
  2. BA researcher who knows which participants were kept awake unconsciously rates their recorded behavior as drowsier when scoring alertness
  3. CParticipants who guess that the study expects tired people to be slower deliberately respond more slowly on the reaction-time taskCorrect
  4. DParticipants respond faster in the second testing session because they have become familiar with the reaction-time task

Why C is right

Demand characteristics are cues in a study that lead participants to guess the hypothesis and then change their behavior to match it, often to be a 'good participant.' In this sleep study (Unit 1, Topic 1.5 Sleep), participants who guess that tired people are expected to be slower and then deliberately slow down produce results that reflect the guessed hypothesis rather than the real effect of sleep loss on reaction time. That is demand characteristics. Choice A is a placebo effect, B is experimenter bias, and D is a practice effect.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because feeling more alert from a drink they only believe is caffeinated is a placebo effect. It comes from what participants expect a treatment to do. Demand characteristics come from participants guessing the study's hypothesis and changing their behavior to fit it.
B
Incorrect because a researcher's knowledge of group assignment shaping how she scores behavior is experimenter bias. That error comes from the researcher, not the participants, and a double-blind procedure is the remedy.
D
Incorrect because faster responses on a repeated test from familiarity with the task are a practice effect, a type of order effect. They do not depend on participants guessing what the study is about.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Biological Bases of Behavior.