Skip to content
AP Psychology · Social Psychology and Personality

Emotion theories

Emotion theories appears in 7 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Social Psychology and Personality. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

These theories disagree about the order of arousal, thinking and feeling. James-Lange says you feel an emotion because you notice your body's arousal. Cannon-Bard says arousal and feeling happen at the same time. Schachter-Singer's two-factor theory says you need arousal plus a cognitive label to name the emotion.

Why it matters

They frame the course's biggest debate about emotion: whether the body or the mind comes first. Lazarus's appraisal theory adds that your judgment of an event can come before, and shape, the emotion itself.

How the exam tests it

A common stem describes arousal plus a cue from the situation and asks which theory fits, and the answer is two-factor theory. The classic evidence for cognition comes from Schachter and Singer's 1962 study. Participants given epinephrine who were not told to expect its arousal effects tended to take on a confederate's mood, becoming more euphoric with a cheerful partner and angrier with an angry one. Participants told what arousal to expect were swayed much less, because the shot already explained how they felt. So arousal with no explanation gets its label from the situation.

Don’t confuse it with

Students confuse Cannon-Bard with James-Lange, so remember that Cannon-Bard rejects the idea that body responses come first, while James-Lange says the body response causes the feeling.

Emotion theories in real questions

Example 1Harder
Which research finding provides the most compelling evidence that cognitive appraisal, rather than physiological arousal alone, determines emotional experience?
  1. APeople with spinal cord injuries report experiencing emotions despite reduced bodily feedback
  2. BIdentical twins show higher concordance in emotional reactivity than fraternal twins, suggesting genetic determination
  3. CBrain imaging reveals that the amygdala is activated before the cortex during fear responses
  4. DThe same physiological arousal can be experienced as different emotions depending on the situational contextCorrect

Why D is right

The strongest evidence for cognitive appraisal's role comes from experiments (Schachter-Singer, Lazarus's film studies) showing that identical physiological arousal is experienced as different emotions depending on situational context and cognitive interpretation. The same arousal from epinephrine is labeled anger in an anger-inducing context and happiness in a euphoria-inducing context, demonstrating that cognition determines the emotion that arousal produces.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because emotion persisting despite reduced bodily feedback challenges the James-Lange theory (and was cited in Cannon-Bard-style arguments); it does not show that cognitive interpretation determines which emotion is felt.
B
Incorrect because twin concordance data address the heritability of emotional reactivity, not whether cognitive appraisal of arousal determines emotional experience.
C
Incorrect because amygdala activation before cortical processing (LeDoux's low road) supports the possibility of pre-cognitive emotional responses; this evidence is typically used to challenge the requirement for cognitive appraisal in emotion generation.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Social Psychology and Personality.