In a clinical trial for a new antidepressant, neither the patients nor the physicians administering the drug know whether a patient is receiving the drug or a sugar pill. Patients in both groups show symptom improvement. Which factor MOST likely explains why the placebo group improved?
- ADemand characteristics, because patients are guessing the study's hypothesis and behaving accordingly
- BRegression to the mean, because patients naturally improve over time regardless of treatment
- CExperimenter bias, because the physicians' expectations are influencing patient outcomes
- DThe placebo effect, because patients' belief in the treatment produces real reliefCorrect
Why D is right
The placebo effect occurs when participants experience real improvements in symptoms because they believe they are receiving an effective treatment, even when they are not. It operates through expectancy and psychological mechanisms that can produce measurable physiological and psychological changes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because demand characteristics occur when participants guess the study's purpose and change behavior accordingly; the placebo effect is about belief in treatment effectiveness, not about figuring out the study's hypothesis.
- B
- Incorrect because regression to the mean is a statistical phenomenon where extreme scores return toward average over time; while it may contribute, the primary psychological explanation for placebo group improvement is the placebo effect.
- C
- Incorrect because experimenter bias involves the researcher's expectations influencing results; in a double-blind study, physicians do not know who receives the drug, so this bias is controlled.