Researchers track a cohort of 500 individuals from birth to age 40, periodically measuring their stress levels, health behaviors, and cardiovascular health. This study design is best described as which type?
- ALongitudinal, because the same group of participants is followed over an extended period of timeCorrect
- BCross-sectional, because participants at multiple life stages are being compared
- CQuasi-experimental, because participants are assigned to groups based on naturally occurring characteristics
- DSequential, because multiple cohorts are followed and compared across different time points
Why A is right
A longitudinal study follows the same participants over an extended period of time (here, 40 years). Advantages include accurate developmental data and the ability to detect change within individuals. Disadvantages include high cost, time commitment, participant attrition (dropout), and potential practice effects from repeated testing.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because a cross-sectional study examines different participants at one point in time; this study follows the same participants repeatedly over decades.
- C
- Incorrect because quasi-experimental research compares naturally occurring groups without random assignment to an independent variable; this study does not have a comparison group and is focused on observing change over time.
- D
- Incorrect because a sequential design combines cross-sectional and longitudinal methods by following multiple cohorts; this study follows a single cohort.
A cross-sequential (sequential cohort) research design is considered superior to both purely longitudinal and purely cross-sectional designs because it:
- AEliminates attrition concerns because each cohort is tracked for a shorter period than in a purely longitudinal design
- BCombines the ability to track within-individual change over time with the ability to control for cohort effects by studying multiple cohortsCorrect
- CProvides faster results than cross-sectional designs by eliminating the need to wait for participants to age
- DEliminates the need for random assignment by comparing multiple cohorts simultaneously
Why B is right
A sequential design follows multiple cohorts (born at different times) longitudinally. It combines advantages of longitudinal research (tracking change within individuals over time) and cross-sectional research (comparing cohorts), while allowing researchers to distinguish developmental changes from cohort effects (differences due to historical context).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because attrition is still a concern in sequential designs; participants must be tracked over time, and dropout can bias results in each cohort's longitudinal portion.
- C
- Incorrect because sequential designs require some longitudinal follow-up; they may be faster than purely longitudinal designs but are slower than purely cross-sectional designs.
- D
- Incorrect because random assignment is an experimental design concern; sequential designs are descriptive/observational and do not involve random assignment.