A health psychologist wants to know whether stress is related to physical illness. Over one semester, 50 college students record how many daily hassles they experience (such as traffic delays and misplaced keys) and how many colds or other minor illnesses they have. The psychologist finds a correlation of r = +0.78 between the two variables. Which of the following is the most accurate interpretation of this finding?
- AThere is a strong positive relationship, but the data cannot show that daily hassles make students more likely to get sickCorrect
- BDaily hassles cause illness, because a correlation of +0.78 is too strong to be explained by any other factor
- CThere is a moderate negative relationship: students who report more daily hassles tend to report fewer illnesses
- DThe relationship is too weak to be meaningful, because r must exceed 0.90 before a correlation counts as strong in psychology
Why A is right
This is a correlational study from health psychology (Unit 5.1, stress and illness). A correlation of r = +0.78 is strong and positive: students who report more daily hassles tend to report more minor illnesses. But correlation does not imply causation. Stress may weaken immune functioning, but illness could also produce more hassles (the directionality problem). A third variable, such as poor sleep or a heavy workload, could also raise both. Only an experiment that manipulates stress and controls other variables could show that hassles cause illness.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because no correlation, however strong, can establish causation. Being sick could produce more hassles (directionality), or a third variable such as poor sleep could increase both hassles and illness.
- C
- Incorrect because the plus sign shows a positive relationship: more hassles go with more illnesses. A value of 0.78 is strong, not moderate. A negative correlation would mean the variables move in opposite directions.
- D
- Incorrect because r = +0.78 is conventionally considered a strong correlation. No rule says r must exceed 0.90 to be meaningful.