A social psychologist studying aggression reviews one city's records for a single summer. She finds that on days when stores sell more cold drinks, police receive more reports of physical fights. She concludes that drinking cold beverages makes people more aggressive. Which concept best explains the error in her conclusion?
- AIllusory correlation, because the link between drink sales and fights in the records does not actually exist statistically
- BThe directionality problem, because fights in the city may lead residents to buy more cold drinks afterward
- CObserver bias, because the researcher's expectations about aggression led her to see a spurious association in the data
- DThe third variable problem, because hot weather may raise both cold-drink sales and irritability that fuels aggressionCorrect
Why D is right
This is the third variable problem: a correlation alone cannot show causation, because an unmeasured variable may cause both measured variables. Here that variable is hot weather. Heat increases cold-drink sales. In social psychology, heat is also a known situational factor that raises irritability and aggression. The correlation between drink sales and fights is real, but concluding that one causes the other ignores the temperature that drives both.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because an illusory correlation means perceiving a relationship that is not in the data. Here the sales and fight records really do vary together; the mistake is the causal conclusion, not the existence of the correlation.
- B
- Incorrect because the directionality problem asks whether B caused A instead of A causing B. Fights causing drink purchases is implausible, and the real issue is an outside variable driving both.
- C
- Incorrect because observer bias means a researcher's expectations distort how data are recorded. Here the data come from store sales and police reports, so the error lies in interpreting a correlation, not in collecting the data.