The Brelands trained a raccoon to pick up coins and deposit them in a metal container for a food reward. Over time, the raccoon began to rub the coins together and dip them in the container repeatedly before releasing them, mimicking food-washing behavior. This behavior, called instinctive drift, best illustrates which principle?
- ABiological preparedness, because the raccoon was genetically predisposed to learn food-related behaviors more easily than arbitrary behaviors
- BSpontaneous recovery, because the raccoon's natural behaviors reappeared after a period during which they had been suppressed through training
- CExtinction, because the reinforcement contingency was no longer effectively maintaining the trained coin-depositing behavior
- DInstinctive drift, because the animal's trained behavior was replaced by species-typical behaviors related to food, despite operant trainingCorrect
Why D is right
Instinctive drift, described by Keller and Marian Breland, refers to the tendency of animals to drift back toward instinctive, species-typical behaviors during training, despite operant conditioning. As the raccoon's trained behavior (depositing coins) became associated with food, the raccoon's innate food-handling instincts (rubbing and washing objects before eating) began to intrude. This demonstrates that biological constraints can limit the power of operant conditioning.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because biological preparedness (Garcia's work) refers to the predisposition to form certain associations more easily than others, particularly taste-illness associations. While related to biological constraints, it specifically describes ease of CS-UCS association formation, not the replacement of learned behaviors with instinctive ones.
- B
- Incorrect because spontaneous recovery refers to the return of an extinguished classically conditioned response after a rest period — not the emergence of species-typical behaviors during active operant training.
- C
- Incorrect because extinction involves the weakening of a behavior when the reinforcer is removed. In instinctive drift, food reinforcement was still being provided — it was the biological pull of instinctive behaviors, not the absence of reinforcement, that disrupted the trained behavior.