Skip to content

AP Physics 1 · technique

How to answer experimental-design questions

On this page · 5 sections

An experimental-design question asks you to plan a lab that finds one physical quantity. Typical targets are a spring constant, a coefficient of friction, the rotational inertia of a disk, or the density of a liquid. You get a setup, a goal and a list of equipment, or permission to use ordinary school lab gear. You then describe what you would measure, how you would measure it, and how you would turn the data into the answer.

On the AP Physics 1 exam this skill is the core of free-response question 3, Experimental Design and Analysis, which is worth 10 points. The procedure part usually carries about three of those points, and the analysis parts depend on it. Multiple-choice questions test the same thinking in smaller pieces. They ask which extra measurement is needed, which variable must be held constant, or which graph would come out as a straight line.

Readers score the procedure point by point, and they reward clarity over length. A procedure earns credit when another student could repeat it from your words alone. That means naming every quantity, the tool that measures it, and where each measurement starts and ends. It also means saying what you keep fixed and what you repeat. A beautiful paragraph that never says how you find the speed earns nothing for speed.

The steps

  1. 1

    1. Write the physics equation first

    Before you touch the procedure, write the equation that links the target quantity to things you can measure. For friction stopping a sliding block, the work-energy theorem gives ½mv² = μmgd, which simplifies to v² = 2μgd. This line tells you exactly what to measure: the speed v and the stopping distance d. Anything not in the equation, like the block's color, does not need measuring. Anything that is in it, like mass, either needs measuring or needs to cancel, as m does here.

  2. 2

    2. Sort the variables

    Choose one independent variable that you change on purpose, and one dependent variable that you measure in response. Everything else that appears in your equation becomes a controlled variable that you hold fixed. In the friction lab, you vary the launch speed and measure the stopping distance. You keep the same block face sliding on the same patch of bench, because changing either contact material or its roughness changes μ. Changing only the block's mass does not change μ, since mass cancels out of v² = 2μgd. Name the controlled variables in your answer, since readers do not assume you thought of them.

  3. 3

    3. Match every quantity to a tool

    For each quantity in your equation, name the instrument and how you use it. Use a meterstick for distances, a balance for mass, and a stopwatch, photogate or motion detector for time and speed. Speed is the step students skip most. A photogate gives speed as v = w/Δt, where w is the width of the flag that blocks the beam and Δt is the blocked time. Slow-motion video against a meterstick also works. Saying "measure the speed" with no tool is not a method.

  4. 4

    4. Write the procedure as numbered steps

    Number your steps, and keep each one to one action. Say where each measurement starts and stops, such as "from the mark where the block's front edge sat as the flag crossed the beam to the front edge where it comes to rest." Say how the motion begins, such as "released from rest" or "launched by hand through the photogate." If a raw reading needs converting, write the conversion, such as a = 2D/t² for a cart released from rest. Short numbered steps are faster to write and easier for a reader to credit.

  5. 5

    5. Build in ways to cut uncertainty

    Plan to change the independent variable over at least five values, spread across a wide range. Repeat each setting three or more times and average the results. Hand timing carries roughly 0.1 to 0.2 seconds of reaction error, so use a photogate or motion detector when one is offered. When only a stopwatch is available, time a longer distance or several oscillations so the error is a smaller share of the total. State the step you take, because "be careful" earns nothing.

  6. 6

    6. Plan the graph before you finish

    Rearrange your equation into the form y = (slope)x + intercept, with the target quantity inside the slope. From v² = 2μgd, graphing v² against d gives a straight line with slope 2μg. Write that statement down in your answer, then show how you would solve it: μ = slope/(2g). This step proves your data can actually produce the target. It also sets up the analysis parts that follow, which are usually worth more points than the procedure.

Worked through

Prompt. You are given a wooden block, a long lab bench, a photogate with a timer, a meterstick and a balance. Design an experiment to find the coefficient of kinetic friction μ between the block and the bench.

Step 1, the physics. Once the block leaves your hand, friction is the only horizontal force on it. Friction does negative work until the kinetic energy is gone, so ½mv² = μmgd. The mass cancels, which leaves v² = 2μgd. You need the speed v at some point and the distance d the block slides after that point. You do not need the mass, so the balance is a distractor.

Step 2, the variables. The independent variable is the launch speed v, which you change by pushing harder or softer. The dependent variable is the stopping distance d. The controlled variables are the surfaces in contact: the same face of the block sliding over the same patch of bench.

Step 3, the procedure. 1. Tape a card flag of width w to the top of the block, and measure w with the meterstick. 2. Place the photogate near one end of the bench. Slide the block slowly by hand until the flag is centered in the beam, and mark the bench at the block's front edge. 3. Push the block so it slides through the photogate. Let go before the flag reaches the beam, so no push acts during or after the measurement. 4. Record the blocked time Δt and calculate v = w/Δt. 5. Measure d with the meterstick, from the mark to the front edge of the block where it stops. Both ends of d now use the same point on the block, so d is the distance slid after the speed was measured. 6. Repeat for at least six different push strengths, spread from slow to fast. Do three trials near each speed.

Step 4, the analysis plan. Graph v² on the vertical axis against d on the horizontal axis. The slope equals 2μg, so μ = slope/(2g). Putting v², which comes from your independent variable, on the vertical axis is fine here. Graphing d against v² also works, with slope 1/(2μg), and either one earns credit as long as you state what the slope equals. If your d has a small constant offset, it only shifts the intercept, so the slope still gives μ.

Step 5, checking with sample data. Suppose the best-fit line passes through (0.10 m, 0.60 m²/s²) and (0.50 m, 2.95 m²/s²). The slope is (2.95 − 0.60)/(0.50 − 0.10) = 2.35/0.40 = 5.9 m/s². Then μ = 5.9/(2 × 9.8) ≈ 0.30, which has no units, as a coefficient of friction should.

Step 6, a typical follow-up. A student repeats the lab with a second identical block stacked on top. What happens to the slope? It stays the same. Friction doubles because the normal force doubles, but the kinetic energy to remove also doubles. The mass cancels, so the slope 2μg contains no mass at all. The surfaces have not changed, so μ is unchanged and the slope is unchanged.

Common mistakes

  • Naming a quantity without a method, such as "find the speed of the block." Every measured quantity needs a tool and a description of how the tool gives that number, like v = w/Δt from a photogate.

  • Leaving out where distances start and stop. "Measure how far it slides" loses credit; "from the mark where the front edge sat as the flag crossed the beam to the front edge at rest" earns it.

  • Running one trial per setting, or testing only two or three settings. A few points can hide a curve or a bad trial, so a strong plan uses five or more values, repeats each one, and says that you average the repeats.

  • Changing two things at once, such as switching to a block with a rubber face and sliding it on a sanded patch of bench in the same run. Name your controlled variables so the reader sees that only the independent variable changes.

  • Measuring things the physics does not need while missing one it does. Write the governing equation first and check every symbol against your list of measurements.

  • Planning to graph the raw variables when the relationship is curved, such as d against v instead of v² against d. Rearrange the equation into a straight-line form and state what the slope equals.

Checklist

  • I wrote the physics equation linking the target quantity to measurable quantities before I wrote any procedure.
  • I named one independent variable, one dependent variable, and the controlled variables I hold fixed.
  • Every quantity in my equation has a named tool and a sentence saying how I use it.
  • Every distance in my procedure says where it starts and where it ends.
  • I change the independent variable over at least five values and repeat each one, and I say that I average.
  • My procedure is in short numbered steps that another student could follow without asking me anything.
  • I stated what to graph on each axis so the data fall on a straight line.
  • I wrote what the slope equals in terms of the target quantity and showed how to solve for it.

More AP Physics 1 technique