A 5 kg block at rest on a frictionless surface is hit by a 1 kg ball. The ball bounces back elastically. Compared to a perfectly inelastic collision with the same ball at the same speed, the block's final speed in the elastic case is:
- AGreater, because the rebounding ball transfers more momentumCorrect
- BLess, because elastic collisions conserve kinetic energy as well as momentum
- CGreater, because elastic collisions release more energy on impact
- DThe same, because momentum is conserved in both collision types
Why A is right
When the ball bounces back, its momentum changes by more than if it had stuck. If the ball approaches with momentum p: Inelastic: all p goes to the system, block gets p/(m_ball + m_block). Elastic: the ball bounces back, so its momentum change is greater (goes from +p to a negative value), and the block receives more momentum. By the impulse-momentum theorem, greater momentum transfer means a greater final speed for the block.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect. Conserving kinetic energy does not reduce the block's speed; the rebounding ball actually transfers more momentum, giving the block a greater final speed.
- C
- Incorrect. The conclusion (block moves faster) is right, but the reasoning is wrong: elastic collisions do not 'release' energy, and the real cause is greater momentum transfer from the rebounding ball.
- D
- Incorrect. Momentum is conserved in both cases, but the ball's final state differs: when it bounces back, more of its momentum is transferred to the block.