Contract farming arrangements, in which agribusiness corporations provide seeds, fertilizers, and technical advice to smallholder farmers who then sell their entire harvest to the company at a pre-agreed price, have expanded rapidly in Southeast Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. Critics argue this system primarily benefits
- Asmallholder farmers, because guaranteed prices eliminate market uncertainty and provide access to seeds and inputs they could not otherwise afford
- Blocal traders and middlemen, who gain new business by buying surplus harvests from contracted farmers at open-market prices
- Ccorporations, which control production decisions and gain a stable supply chain while shifting crop-failure risk onto individual farmersCorrect
- Dnational governments, because export-oriented contract farming boosts agricultural tax revenue and strengthens the country's trade balance
- Econsumers in wealthy countries, who benefit from lower food prices as more efficient global supply chains reduce commodity costs
Why C is right
Critics of contract farming argue that while farmers gain some input access and price certainty, corporations benefit most: they direct what, when, and how to grow without owning land, shift weather and crop failure risk to farmers who bear the costs of bad harvests, and lock farmers into exclusive contracts that limit market alternatives.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- This describes the perspective of contract farming advocates, not critics; critics argue these apparent benefits mask corporate control and risk transfer to vulnerable smallholders.
- B
- Contract farmers sell their entire harvest to the company, so there is no surplus left for local traders. Contract farming actually bypasses middlemen, linking producers directly to agribusiness. A student who picks this has mistaken vertical integration for a wider local market.
- D
- While export agriculture does generate tax revenue, critics of contract farming focus on the distribution of benefits between corporations and farmers, not on national fiscal outcomes.
- E
- Lower consumer prices in wealthy countries may result, but critics of contract farming focus on inequality in the global commodity chain—the exploitation of small producers—not on consumer price benefits.