The table shows hypothetical data from four farm systems in the same region, each averaged over ten years.
| Farm system | Carbon stored in trees and soil (t/ha) | Annual soil loss (t/ha) | Maize yield (t/ha) | Synthetic nitrogen fertilizer (kg/ha) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maize monoculture | 45 | 18 | 6.0 | 150 |
| Maize with tree rows (alley cropping) | 82 | 6 | 5.1 | 90 |
| Maize with scattered shade trees | 68 | 9 | 5.5 | 110 |
| Maize under dense tree canopy | 110 | 3 | 3.2 | 60 |
A researcher argues that integrating trees with crops (agroforestry) offers environmental advantages over monoculture farming. Which of the following statements is supported by the data in the table?
- AScattered shade trees stored more carbon than alley cropping did and also lost less soil each year
- BDense tree canopy more than doubled carbon storage relative to monoculture while keeping maize yield within 10 percent of it
- CRelative to monoculture, scattered shade trees reduced maize yield by a larger percentage than they reduced soil loss
- DDense tree canopy used less than half the fertilizer of monoculture and lost less than one-tenth as much soil
- ERelative to monoculture, alley cropping cut soil loss by two-thirds and fertilizer use by 40 percent while lowering maize yield by only 15 percentCorrect
Why E is right
Compare the alley-cropping row with the monoculture row. Soil loss fell from 18 to 6 t/ha, a two-thirds reduction. Fertilizer fell from 150 to 90 kg/ha, a 40 percent reduction. Maize yield fell from 6.0 to 5.1 t/ha, a 15 percent reduction. Choice E states all three correctly. It also shows the agroforestry trade-off: trees reduce erosion and the need for synthetic inputs and store more carbon, at a modest cost in crop output. Each of the other choices misreads a row, a ratio, or the direction of a comparison.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- This reads the wrong rows. Scattered shade trees stored less carbon than alley cropping (68 vs. 82 t/ha) and lost more soil (9 vs. 6 t/ha).
- B
- The carbon half is true (110 vs. 45 t/ha), but dense canopy cut maize yield from 6.0 to 3.2 t/ha, about 47 percent, which is far outside 10 percent. This misses the yield trade-off.
- C
- This reverses the comparison. Scattered shade trees lowered yield by about 8 percent (6.0 to 5.5 t/ha) but cut soil loss by 50 percent (18 to 9 t/ha), so the yield drop was the smaller one.
- D
- The fertilizer half is true (60 vs. 150 kg/ha, 40 percent). But soil loss of 3 vs. 18 t/ha is one-sixth of the monoculture's, not less than one-tenth, so this misreads the ratio.