In which of the following scenarios would thermohaline circulation be MOST disrupted?
- ARapid melting of the Greenland ice sheet, discharging large volumes of cold, fresh water into the North AtlanticCorrect
- BAn increase in global wind speeds that enhances surface wave mixing in the North Atlantic
- CA strong El Niño event, warming tropical Pacific Ocean surface temperatures by 1-2°C
- DA major volcanic eruption releasing sulfur dioxide into the stratosphere, temporarily cooling surface temperatures
Why A is right
Thermohaline circulation is driven by the sinking of cold, salty (dense) water in the North Atlantic. If large volumes of cold freshwater are discharged from melting of the Greenland ice sheet, this freshwater mixes with and dilutes the salty surface water, reducing its salinity and density. Less dense surface water cannot sink, reducing or stopping the 'pump' that drives deep water formation. Paleoclimate evidence (Younger Dryas cold event ~12,900 years ago) suggests that freshwater pulses from melting glaciers did shut down thermohaline circulation, causing rapid cooling in Europe.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Increased wind speeds enhance surface mixing and potentially increase evaporation (raising salinity slightly), which would actually maintain or strengthen thermohaline circulation rather than disrupt it; wind-driven mixing increases the density of surface waters.
- C
- El Niño warming in the Pacific affects global precipitation and temperature patterns but does not directly affect North Atlantic salinity, which is the key driver of thermohaline deep water formation; Pacific ENSO events have only indirect effects on AMOC.
- D
- Volcanic eruptions that cool surface temperatures would actually enhance thermohaline circulation by increasing the density (through cooling) of North Atlantic surface waters, making them sink more readily — the opposite of disruption.