Which of the following best illustrates a negative feedback loop in Earth's climate system involving plants?
- AAs temperatures rise, more water evaporates, increasing atmospheric water vapor, a greenhouse gas that traps more heat
- BAs Arctic ice melts, darker ocean absorbs more sunlight, causing further warming and more ice melt
- CAs CO2 increases, plant growth is stimulated, and plants absorb more CO2, partially offsetting the increaseCorrect
- DAs CO2 increases, temperatures rise, which causes more permafrost to thaw, releasing more CO2
Why C is right
CO2 fertilization of plants is a negative feedback: increased atmospheric CO2 stimulates photosynthesis in many plant species, causing them to absorb more CO2 and temporarily slow the rate of atmospheric CO2 increase. However, this negative feedback is limited — it can only partially offset emissions and may diminish as other nutrients (nitrogen, phosphorus) become limiting.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. This is a positive feedback (water vapor feedback): warming -> more evaporation -> more water vapor (a greenhouse gas) -> more warming. It amplifies rather than dampens the initial warming.
- B
- Incorrect. This is the ice-albedo positive feedback: warming -> ice melt -> lower albedo -> more absorption -> more warming. It amplifies the initial change.
- D
- Incorrect. This is a positive feedback (permafrost-carbon feedback): warming -> permafrost thaw -> more CO2/CH4 release -> more warming. It amplifies the initial change rather than counteracting it.