A city plans to reduce its carbon emissions from electricity by 50% within 10 years. Its current electricity mix is: coal 60%, natural gas 25%, nuclear 10%, renewables 5%. Using the lifecycle emissions data (coal: 820 g CO2/kWh, gas: 490 g CO2/kWh, nuclear: 12 g CO2/kWh, renewables: 30 g CO2/kWh), which combination of changes would most likely achieve the 50% reduction target?
- ADouble nuclear power from 10% to 20% while keeping coal at 60%
- BIncrease renewable energy from 5% to 15% while keeping coal and gas the same
- CRetire all coal plants and replace them with 30% natural gas and 30% wind/solarCorrect
- DReplace all coal with natural gas, keeping other sources the same
Why C is right
Current emissions per kWh = (0.60 x 820) + (0.25 x 490) + (0.10 x 12) + (0.05 x 30) = 492 + 122.5 + 1.2 + 1.5 = 617.2 g/kWh. Option B: (0.30 x 490) + (0.25 x 490) + (0.10 x 12) + (0.35 x 30) = 147 + 122.5 + 1.2 + 10.5 = 281.2 g/kWh. Reduction = (617.2 - 281.2)/617.2 = 54.4%, achieving the target.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Doubling nuclear to 20%: (0.60 x 820) + (0.15 x 490) + (0.20 x 12) + (0.05 x 30) = 492 + 73.5 + 2.4 + 1.5 = 569.4 g/kWh. Reduction = (617.2 - 569.4)/617.2 = 7.7%, far below the 50% target.
- B
- Incorrect. Increasing renewables to 15%: (0.60 x 820) + (0.25 x 490) + (0.10 x 12) + (0.15 x 30) = 492 + 122.5 + 1.2 + 4.5 = 620.2 g/kWh (actually increases slightly because the 10% added to renewables must come from somewhere, and as stated this doesn't reduce coal). This barely changes emissions.
- D
- Incorrect. Replacing coal with gas: (0.85 x 490) + (0.10 x 12) + (0.05 x 30) = 416.5 + 1.2 + 1.5 = 419.2 g/kWh. Reduction = (617.2 - 419.2)/617.2 = 32.1%, falling short of 50%.