Scientists studying ice cores from Antarctica have reconstructed atmospheric CO2 and temperature records going back 800,000 years. Which of the following conclusions is most strongly supported by these ice core data?
- ACO2 concentrations during past ice ages ranged from 400-500 ppm, suggesting current levels represent a return to natural ice-age baselines.
- BCurrent atmospheric CO2 levels (~420 ppm) are unprecedented in the 800,000-year record, exceeding any prior interglacial maximum.Correct
- CThe ice core record shows no relationship between CO2 and temperature, indicating CO2 is not a driver of past climate change.
- DTemperature during past interglacials was consistently 5-8°C warmer than today, indicating current warming is modest by historical standards.
Why B is right
Ice core data (EPICA, Vostok) show that over the past 800,000 years, CO2 oscillated between approximately 180 ppm (glacial maxima) and 280 ppm (interglacial maxima). Current CO2 (~420 ppm) far exceeds all values in this 800,000-year record. To find CO2 this high, one must look back to the Pliocene (~3-5 million years ago) when CO2 was last ~300-400 ppm and sea levels were 5-20 meters higher. This is a key line of evidence that current anthropogenic emissions are driving atmospheric composition outside the range of natural variability experienced throughout human prehistory.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. This is factually backward. CO2 during past ice ages was approximately 180-190 ppm—much lower than current levels, not 400-500 ppm. During interglacials, CO2 reached about 280 ppm. Current 420 ppm greatly exceeds all ice-age and interglacial values in the record.
- C
- Incorrect. Ice core data actually show a clear correlation between CO2 concentrations and temperature proxies (deuterium/oxygen isotopes) across glacial-interglacial cycles. However, in this case CO2 often lagged temperature slightly, as orbital forcing initially caused warming that released CO2 from oceans, amplifying the warming—confirming CO2 as a positive feedback in natural cycles.
- D
- Incorrect. Past interglacials were not consistently 5-8°C warmer than today. The warmest interglacials (like MIS 5e, ~125,000 years ago) were approximately 1-2°C warmer than pre-industrial. Current warming is approaching or exceeding the warmest interglacial temperatures in many regions.