Skip to content

Free-response practice

FRQ 2

10 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

FRQ 2 is the middle question of the AP Environmental Science free-response section. It hands you a real-world environmental problem and asks you to reason through it from start to finish. The stimulus is usually a short passage plus a table, graph or map. The parts are labelled (a), (b), (c) and so on, and some have sub-parts. They usually move in this order: read the data, identify the sources or players, explain the mechanism that causes the harm, propose a solution, then judge its costs or consequences. The exact order and mix of tasks change from year to year, so read every part before you start. FRQ 2 does not ask for calculations, because calculations belong to FRQ 3.

On this page · 6 sections

The free-response section is 70 minutes for three questions and counts for 40% of your exam score. Each question is worth 10 points, so FRQ 2 alone is roughly 13% of your total score. Spending about 23 minutes on it keeps you on pace.

Readers score each point on its own merits against a checklist, so missing part (a) does not stop you earning part (c). Some parts build on an earlier answer, such as "the solution you proposed in part (e)". Readers still score that later part, but they judge it against what you wrote earlier, so make sure it matches your earlier answer. The task verb sets the bar for each point: - "Identify" needs a correct, specific name or value. - "Describe" needs the relevant features. - "Explain" needs a cause-and-effect chain: how or why something happens.

When a part asks for one answer, readers generally score only the first one you give. Listing three guesses does not help. Restating the prompt earns nothing. A specific, correct mechanism written in plain sentences earns the point, and spelling or grammar does not matter.

The rubric, in plain terms

10 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Read the stimulus1 pt

Pull a correct value, trend or feature from the table, graph or passage, and answer exactly the question asked. If the part asks when a threshold was first crossed, give that month, not the month with the extreme value.

Identify sources, agents or organisms2 pts

Name two specific items the prompt asks for, one point each. Examples are a point source and a nonpoint source, or the gas responsible plus an organism affected. Each answer must fit the scenario and the category. Calling urban street runoff a point source loses the point.

Explain the mechanism3 pts

Give the cause-and-effect steps that link the human activity to the harm, one point per step. For example, nitrate triggers an algal bloom, and then bacteria decomposing the dead algae use up oxygen. A skipped step does not earn its point, so writing "the algae use up the oxygen" misses the decomposition step that readers credit. A separate physical or chemical factor can earn a point of its own. For temperature, accepted reasons include that warm water holds less dissolved oxygen, that warm surface water stratifies the water column so oxygen cannot mix down to the bottom, and that heat speeds up decomposer respiration.

Propose and describe a solution2 pts

One point for a specific, workable solution that fits the scale the prompt asks for. One point for describing how it reduces the problem at its source or along its path. Vague wishes ("people should care more") and chemically impossible fixes (turning CO2 into oxygen on a smokestack) earn neither point.

Evaluate costs and consequences2 pts

One point for a disadvantage that belongs to the solution you proposed: who bears the cost and why. One point for linking the environmental harm to a concrete human consequence, such as a named ecosystem service, an industry, or income and jobs.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Summer Dead Zone in an Agricultural Estuary

Harlow Bay is a shallow estuary fed by the Tessic River. The river drains about 4,200 square kilometers of corn and soybean farmland. It also passes the city of Avonford (population 90,000), whose wastewater treatment plant empties into the river through a single outfall pipe. The plant was built in 1978 and does not remove nitrogen. For the past decade, local fishers have reported that blue crabs and striped bass disappear from the deeper parts of the bay every late summer. In 2025 a state agency measured conditions at one deep station in the bay.

Month | Nitrate delivered by river (metric tons) | Bottom-water dissolved oxygen (mg/L) | Bottom-water temperature (°C) April | 410 | 7.8 | 12 May | 520 | 6.1 | 16 June | 380 | 3.9 | 21 July | 210 | 1.6 | 25 August | 150 | 1.2 | 26 September | 140 | 2.8 | 22

Water with less than 2 mg/L of dissolved oxygen is considered hypoxic.

  1. (a)Using the data, identify the first month in 2025 in which bottom water at the station was hypoxic. [1 pt]
  2. (b)Identify one nonpoint source and one point source of nitrogen entering Harlow Bay. [2 pts]
  3. (c)Explain how nitrate delivered by the river in spring leads to the low dissolved oxygen recorded in late summer. [2 pts]
  4. (d)Using the temperature data, explain one reason other than nutrient loading that bottom-water dissolved oxygen is lowest in July and August. [1 pt]
  5. (e)Propose one solution that would reduce the nitrogen reaching Harlow Bay from farmland, and describe how it would reduce that nitrogen. [2 pts]
  6. (f)Describe one disadvantage of the solution you proposed in part (e). Then explain how the summer hypoxia harms one ecosystem service that Harlow Bay provides to people. [2 pts]
Prompt 2

Falling pH at a Pacific Oyster Hatchery

Kestrel Inlet is an arm of the Pacific Ocean where a commercial hatchery raises oyster larvae for shellfish farms along the coast. During their first two days, the larvae build a shell from calcium carbonate drawn out of the surrounding seawater. Hatchery staff have noticed that mass die-offs happen most often a day or two after strong winds push surface water offshore. When that happens, deep water rises to replace it along the coast, a process called upwelling. A monitoring buoy near the hatchery has recorded surface seawater pH since 1990.

Year | Mean surface seawater pH | Atmospheric CO2 (ppm) | Larval survival to day 10 (%) 1990 | 8.11 | 354 | 78 2000 | 8.09 | 370 | 74 2010 | 8.06 | 390 | 61 2020 | 8.04 | 414 | 52

  1. (a)Describe the trend in mean surface seawater pH from 1990 to 2020, and state what the trend means for the acidity of the water. [1 pt]
  2. (b)(i) Identify the gas in the table whose increase drives the pH trend. (ii) Identify one marine organism other than oysters that is directly threatened by this change in pH. [2 pts]
  3. (c)(i) Explain how an increase in the gas you identified in (b)(i) lowers the pH of seawater. (ii) Explain why lower pH makes it harder for oyster larvae to build their shells. [2 pts]
  4. (d)Explain why larval die-offs at the hatchery are most common shortly after upwelling events. [1 pt]
  5. (e)Propose one national or international policy that would slow the pH trend shown in the table, and describe how it would do so. [2 pts]
  6. (f)Describe one disadvantage of the policy you proposed in part (e). Then explain one economic effect on coastal communities if seawater pH continues to fall. [2 pts]

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Summer Dead Zone in an Agricultural Estuary · high-scoring response10/10

(a) July. Dissolved oxygen is 1.6 mg/L, which is below the 2 mg/L hypoxia line. June is still 3.9 so it is not hypoxic yet.

(b) Nonpoint source: fertilizer washing off the corn and soybean fields when it rains. It comes from thousands of fields spread over the watershed, not one spot. Point source: the Avonford wastewater treatment plant, because it discharges through one outfall pipe you can point to.

(c) Nitrogen is usually the limiting nutrient in coastal water, so the spring nitrate causes a big algal bloom in the bay. The algae die off when they run out of nutrients or shade each other. The dead algae sink to the bottom, where aerobic bacteria decompose them. The bacteria use up dissolved oxygen faster than it can be replaced from the surface. This takes weeks, which is why the oxygen low comes in July and August even though nitrate peaked in May.

(d) Bottom water warms from 12°C in April to 26°C in August. Warm water can hold less dissolved oxygen than cold water, so the bottom water starts out with less O2 even before decomposers use any.

(e) Farmers could plant riparian buffer strips of grass and trees along the Tessic River and the streams that feed it. The plant roots take up nitrate from runoff and shallow groundwater before it reaches the river. The vegetation also slows the water down so soil and the fertilizer stuck to it settle out.

(f) A disadvantage is that land in the buffer strip can't be farmed, so farmers grow fewer crops and earn less unless the state pays them. The hypoxia harms the bay's provisioning service of food. Crabs and striped bass leave or suffocate in the low-oxygen bottom water, so fishers catch less and lose income.

How it scored

1/1a — Correctly picks July as the first month below 2 mg/L. Checking June shows the student read the threshold, not just the lowest value.
2/2b — Farm fertilizer runoff is a correct nonpoint source and the treatment plant outfall is a correct point source. Both reasons show the student knows the difference: spread-out sources versus one discharge pipe.
2/2c — Full chain. Nutrients cause a bloom (1), and bacteria decomposing the dead algae consume oxygen (1). The time lag is explained as a bonus.
1/1d — Uses the temperature data and gives a physical reason that is separate from nutrients: warm water dissolves less oxygen.
2/2e — Riparian buffers are a specific, workable farm-scale solution (1). The answer describes how roots absorb nitrate and vegetation slows runoff (1).
2/2f — The disadvantage belongs to the proposed buffers and names who pays: farmers losing cropland (1). Names a provisioning service and links it to fish loss and fishers' income (1).
Summer Dead Zone in an Agricultural Estuary · mid-scoring response5/10

(a) August, because that is when the oxygen is the lowest at 1.2.

(b) The nonpoint source is the fertilizer from all the farms. The point source is runoff from the streets in Avonford.

(c) The nitrate is a fertilizer so it makes algae grow really fast, which is called an algal bloom. The algae use up all the oxygen in the water and then the fish can't breathe and die.

(d) In July and August the water is warmer, so the algae grow even faster and more oxygen gets used up.

(e) Farmers could test their soil and only put on as much fertilizer as the crops actually need. Then there won't be extra nitrogen left in the soil to wash into the river when it rains.

(f) A disadvantage is that it would cost a lot of money. The hypoxia hurts fishing in the bay because the crabs and bass leave or die, so the fishermen can't catch as much and lose money.

How it scored

0/1a — Gives the month with the lowest oxygen instead of the first month below 2 mg/L. July already qualifies, so the answer misreads the question.
1/2b — Farm fertilizer is a correct nonpoint source (1). Runoff from city streets is also nonpoint, because it enters from many drains and surfaces, so it cannot be the point source (0). The treatment plant pipe was the answer.
1/2c — Nitrate causing an algal bloom earns 1. Saying the algae themselves use up the oxygen skips the key step. The oxygen is consumed by bacteria decomposing the dead algae (0).
0/1d — The prompt asked for a reason other than nutrients, but this answer loops back to algae growth. It never says that warm water holds less dissolved oxygen.
2/2e — Matching fertilizer to crop need (precision application) is a specific, workable solution (1). It explains that no surplus nitrogen is left to run off (1).
1/2f — "Costs a lot of money" is too vague and does not fit this solution: using less fertilizer saves money on fertilizer. A possible real disadvantage is lower yields if too little is applied (0). Linking hypoxia to fewer crabs and bass and lost fishing income earns the ecosystem-service point (1).
Falling pH at a Pacific Oyster Hatchery · high-scoring response9/10

(a) Surface pH dropped steadily from 8.11 in 1990 to 8.04 in 2020. The water is still slightly basic but is becoming more acidic. Because pH is a log scale, a 0.07 drop means about 17% more hydrogen ions.

(b) (i) Carbon dioxide (CO2). (ii) Reef-building corals, because they build their skeletons out of calcium carbonate just like oyster shells.

(c) (i) CO2 from burning fossil fuels dissolves into the ocean surface and reacts with water to form carbonic acid (H2CO3). Carbonic acid breaks apart and releases H+ ions, and more H+ means lower pH. (ii) The extra H+ ions combine with carbonate ions (CO3 2-) to make bicarbonate, so fewer carbonate ions are left in the water. Larvae need carbonate to make calcium carbonate shells. With less of it around, building a shell takes more energy, and thin shells can even start to dissolve.

(d) Upwelling brings nutrient-rich deep water to the surface. This causes algal blooms, and when the algae decompose the oxygen drops, so the larvae suffocate.

(e) The federal government could require stricter fuel efficiency standards for new cars and trucks. It could also fund public transit and electric vehicle charging stations. Cars would burn less gasoline per mile and people would drive fewer gas-powered miles. That puts less CO2 in the atmosphere, so less dissolves into the ocean.

(f) A disadvantage is that building more efficient vehicles costs automakers more, so new car prices go up, which hurts lower-income buyers. If pH keeps falling, hatcheries like this one will keep losing larvae, so shellfish farms will have fewer oysters to sell. Workers could lose jobs, and the restaurants and seafood businesses that depend on local oysters would lose money too.

How it scored

1/1a — Correct direction and correct meaning (more acidic). The log-scale point is accurate extra detail.
2/2b — CO2 is correct (1). Corals are a calcifying organism, and the answer justifies the choice through calcium carbonate (1).
2/2c — (i) gives the full chain: CO2 dissolves, forms carbonic acid, and releases H+ (1). (ii) correctly says that H+ ties up carbonate ions, so less is available for building CaCO3 (1).
0/1d — Applies the eutrophication story to the wrong problem. Die-offs come a day or two after upwelling, which is too fast for a bloom-and-decay cycle. Deep water carries extra dissolved CO2 from organic matter decomposing as it sinks, so upwelled water has lower pH. That was the needed link.
2/2e — A specific national policy with several parts (1). It describes how the policy reduces fossil fuel combustion and the CO2 that ends up in the ocean (1).
2/2f — The disadvantage belongs to the policy and names who bears the cost (1). Gives a clear economic chain: lost larvae, fewer oysters sold, lost jobs and business income (1).
Falling pH at a Pacific Oyster Hatchery · mid-scoring response5/10

(a) The pH went down from 8.11 to 8.04, so the water is getting more acidic.

(b) (i) Carbon dioxide. (ii) Jellyfish, because they are very sensitive to changes in the water.

(c) (i) When there is more CO2 in the air, it dissolves into the ocean and forms carbonic acid, which makes the water more acidic. (ii) The acid burns the baby oysters and dissolves them so they can't survive.

(d) Upwelling brings up water from deep down, which is colder and has more CO2 in it, so the pH is even lower than normal.

(e) Power plants should put catalytic converters on their smokestacks. The converters would turn the CO2 into oxygen before it gets released, so less CO2 goes into the air and the ocean.

(f) One disadvantage is that it would be really expensive. If the pH keeps dropping, oyster farms will go out of business because the oysters keep dying, so the town loses jobs and money.

How it scored

1/1a — Correct trend with values, and correctly says the water is becoming more acidic.
1/2b — CO2 is correct (1). Jellyfish are soft-bodied and do not build calcium carbonate structures, so lower carbonate does not directly threaten them (0).
1/2c — (i) links CO2 to carbonic acid and acidity (1). (ii) says acid "burns" the larvae and never mentions carbonate ions. It does not explain why shell building gets harder (0).
1/1d — Correctly says upwelled deep water carries more CO2 and so has lower pH. That explains why die-offs follow upwelling.
0/2e — Catalytic converters cannot turn CO2 into oxygen. They are built for exhaust pollutants such as CO and NOx. A solution that cannot work earns neither the proposal point nor the description point.
1/2f — "Really expensive" does not say who pays or why, so it is too vague to earn the disadvantage point (0). The economic chain of dying oysters, failing farms and lost jobs earns the point (1).

Where points die

Calling any pollution from a town a "point source", for example runoff from city streets, parking lots or lawns. A point source enters through one identifiable outlet, such as a sewage plant outfall, a factory pipe or a smokestack. Runoff that drains off many streets, roofs and fields is nonpoint, even inside a city. If you can't name the single pipe, it is nonpoint.

Writing that "the algae use up the oxygen" in a eutrophication question. Living algae add oxygen by photosynthesis in daylight, although they also respire at night. The bottom-water oxygen crash comes later, and bacteria drive it. The bloom dies and sinks, then aerobic bacteria decompose it and use dissolved oxygen faster than it is replaced. The full chain is: nutrients, bloom, die-off, decomposition, oxygen loss, fish kills. Readers look for the decomposition step by name.

Naming an organism that does not build calcium carbonate, such as jellyfish, whales or deep-sea vent bacteria, as the group most harmed by ocean acidification. Acidification hurts organisms that build calcium carbonate shells or skeletons. Extra H+ ions tie up carbonate ions, so less is left for building CaCO3. Name corals, oysters, clams, sea urchins, pteropods or coccolithophores, and say "calcium carbonate" in your reason.

Proposing a solution that cannot work, such as catalytic converters that turn CO2 into oxygen, or rock dust that "blocks sunlight" to lock away carbon. Catalytic converters treat CO, NOx and unburned hydrocarbons in exhaust, not CO2. Real CO2 options cut fossil fuel burning or store the carbon. Examples are fuel efficiency standards, transit and EV charging, renewable power, and carbon capture and storage. CCS captures CO2 at a power plant, compresses it and injects it into deep rock formations.

Giving a solution that is too weak or too extreme for the scale asked, such as an awareness campaign, or an immediate ban on all gasoline cars. Awareness campaigns alone have produced only small cuts in driving, and an overnight ban is politically and practically impossible. Pick a structural policy that fits the scale in the prompt and that people could carry out. Then say exactly how it reduces the pollutant at its source.

Judging a greenhouse gas by how much is released instead of how strongly it warms, for example naming CO2 or water vapor as the most potent gas from thawing permafrost. CO2 is the reference gas, with a global warming potential (GWP) of 1. Methane traps roughly 80 times more heat than CO2 over 20 years, and it comes from waterlogged, oxygen-poor thawing soil. Water vapor is a feedback, because warmer air holds more of it, and it is not emitted by the permafrost. Read whether the stem asks for "most released" or "most potent".

Score your own response

0 / 10

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.