Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Uncanny

Uncanny appears in 6 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Uncanny is tested

Example 1Harder
Read the following passage, then answer the question. From an experimental postmodern prose piece about an anonymous letter: "The letter had no signature. This was its most important feature: not the accusations it contained, not the evidence it cited, not the date it was written, but the absence of the name at the bottom. The letter's authors could have been anyone, and because of this they were in some sense everyone. The recipient read it three times, trying to hear a voice in it, and found each time a different voice—her sister's once, a colleague's once, and once, most disturbingly, her own. This was what the unsigned letter did: it returned the reader's own fears to her in handwriting she could not attribute." The unsigned letter most directly functions as a symbol of:
  1. AAnagnorisis: each successive reading of the letter brings the recipient closer to a decisive recognition of the letter's true author and its origin
  2. BPathetic fallacy: the letter's emotional content mirrors the recipient's own psychological state, attributing her turmoil to an outside object
  3. CDramatic irony: the reader of the novel already knows who composed the letter even as the recipient herself cannot determine its true source
  4. DProjection and the uncanny return of the self: because no author can be identified, the letter reflects the recipient's own repressed fears back to herCorrect

Why D is right

The letter functions as a projective surface: without a signature, it cannot be located in a specific other, and so the reader's own 'fears' return to her 'in handwriting she could not attribute.' The passage makes this explicit: she hears her own voice in it on the third reading. The letter is uncanny—something that seems external but is recognized as originating within. The symbol is of projection and the self's capacity to inhabit anonymous accusations.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Anagnorisis requires movement toward a final recognition; the passage presents three different voices in three readings with no convergence—the process is centrifugal, not converging toward a single truth.
B
Pathetic fallacy attributes emotion to the natural or physical environment; the letter is a human-made document that the recipient actively interprets—the mirroring is psychological, not environmental.
C
No author has been established for the reader of the novel; the narrative presents the letter's origin as genuinely indeterminate, so no dramatic irony gap exists.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.