Read the following passage carefully before choosing your answer.
The restaurant had been in the family for three generations, and its menu had not changed in any of them -- the same dumplings, the same broth, the same chili oil mixed to a recipe that existed nowhere on paper because paper could be stolen, burned, or misread. The recipe existed only in the hands of whoever mixed it, passed from mother to daughter-in-law through demonstration, never description. Words were too clumsy for the work: 'a little sesame' could mean anything, but the particular twist of the wrist that released exactly enough sesame from the jar -- that meant only one thing and could not be misunderstood by anyone who had been shown.
The passage's discussion of the chili oil recipe primarily explores the distinction between
- Athe commercial secrecy that competing family restaurants must protect
- Bknowledge that can be put into words and knowledge that can only be shownCorrect
- CChinese and Western approaches to teaching culinary technique
- Dthe exacting standards of professional kitchens versus casual home cooking
Why B is right
The passage contrasts knowledge that exists on paper (which 'could be stolen, burned, or misread') with knowledge that exists 'only in the hands of whoever mixed it,' passed through 'demonstration, never description.' The specific example of 'a little sesame' (linguistically imprecise) versus the wrist twist (physically precise) illustrates the distinction between articulable, propositional knowledge and tacit, embodied knowledge that can only be shown.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because, while leaving the recipe unwritten does offer some protection from theft, the passage emphasizes an epistemological point about embodied knowledge rather than commercial secrecy or business competition.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage never references Western culinary traditions; it explores a universal distinction between verbal and demonstrated knowledge within a single cultural practice.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage describes an entirely professional restaurant kitchen; its concern is the mode of knowledge transmission, not a contrast between professional and home-cooking standards.