Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Rhetorical strategy

Rhetorical strategy appears in 4 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Rhetorical strategy is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage carefully before choosing your answer. I told them the fire started by itself, and maybe it did. The curtains had been breathing all afternoon, pulling in the hot wind from the savannah and pushing it back out again, and who is to say what a curtain might decide to do when it has been breathing long enough? Father Okello said I was lying, but Father Okello says many things from behind his wooden desk, things about sin and consequence that have the shape of truth without the weight of it. The matches were in my pocket, yes, I will not deny this. But matches live in pockets. That is what pockets are for. And if the fire took the schoolhouse and left the church standing, perhaps that tells you something about which building God preferred. The narrator's rhetorical strategy in this passage is best characterized as
  1. Aimpassioned denunciation of religious hypocrisy and institutional authority
  2. Bdetached, objective reporting of events without personal interpretation
  3. Csincere confession of guilt tempered by genuine spiritual remorse
  4. Devasive self-justification disguised as philosophical reasoningCorrect

Why D is right

The narrator employs sophisticated rhetorical evasion, personifying curtains as capable of decision-making, dismissing Father Okello's authority, and reframing the fire's selective destruction as divine preference. Each argument deflects personal responsibility while appearing to engage in honest reasoning.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the narrator's dismissal of Father Okello is wry and offhand rather than an impassioned denunciation of religious hypocrisy.
B
Incorrect because the passage is saturated with personal interpretation—personified curtains, theological speculation about God's preference—so it is anything but detached, objective reporting.
C
Incorrect because the narrator expresses no remorse or guilt; the passage runs on deflection and self-serving logic rather than sincere confession.
Example 2Medium
Read the following dramatic excerpt carefully before choosing your answer. JUDGE WARREN: (reviewing documents) You understand the charges. MRS. OAKES: I understand the words. The meaning is something else. JUDGE WARREN: The meaning is plain. You harbored a fugitive. MRS. OAKES: I fed a hungry man. That he was also a fugitive is a fact about him. That I fed him is a fact about me. These are different facts, Your Honor, and they require different judgments. JUDGE WARREN: The law does not draw such fine distinctions. MRS. OAKES: Then the law is not fine enough. (Silence in the courtroom.) JUDGE WARREN: (slowly) You are either very brave or very foolish, Mrs. Oakes. MRS. OAKES: I have found, Your Honor, that the two are often indistinguishable. Mrs. Oakes's rhetorical strategy throughout this exchange is best characterized as
  1. Aundermining the court's authority by refusing to acknowledge the legitimacy of the legal system
  2. Breframing the legal narrative by insisting on a moral distinction the law does not recognizeCorrect
  3. Cappealing to the judge's emotions by describing the fugitive's suffering in vivid detail
  4. Dusing flattery and deference to persuade the judge to exercise leniency

Why B is right

Mrs. Oakes consistently reframes the situation: she separates the act of feeding a hungry person from the act of harboring a fugitive, insisting these are 'different facts' requiring 'different judgments.' She does not deny the legal charge but argues that moral reality is more complex than legal categories allow, effectively challenging the law's adequacy rather than its authority.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because Mrs. Oakes engages respectfully with the court ('Your Honor') and does not reject legal authority; she argues the law should be more nuanced, not that it is illegitimate.
C
Incorrect because Mrs. Oakes does not describe the fugitive's suffering or appeal to emotion; her argument is logical and philosophical, based on distinguishing categories of action.
D
Incorrect because Mrs. Oakes is direct and even challenging ('Then the law is not fine enough'), showing no deference or flattery in her approach.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.