Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Rhetorical device

Rhetorical device appears in 6 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Rhetorical device is tested

Example 1Harder
Read the following poem. Kitchen God Every night before bed my grandmother offered the kitchen god a piece of sugar cane. Not prayer—an arrangement. He would report good things at New Year. She would keep the sugar coming. I watched from the doorway and understood commerce before I understood faith: that the divine requires tending, that the sacred and the practical share the same kitchen, that the woman who keeps the house keeps the world. My grandmother died and the kitchen god went with her—or rather, the arrangement ended and the kitchen became only a kitchen. I still buy sugar cane sometimes. I don't know what I'm doing when I do. The poem's self-correction—'went with her—or rather, the arrangement ended'—primarily accomplishes which effect?
  1. AIt establishes the speaker's fully secular worldview by rejecting the grandmother's religious framework and replacing it with a sociological account of ritual
  2. BIt distinguishes the god's existence from the relationship's existence, preserving mystery about the former while marking the end of the latterCorrect
  3. CIt signals the speaker's grief by enacting the confusion of the bereaved, who cannot accurately name or describe what has actually been lost
  4. DIt contradicts the grandmother's animistic belief by insisting that the kitchen god was never real and that ritual functions only through its human practitioner

Why B is right

The self-correction is philosophically careful: 'went with her' implies the god was the grandmother's property or only real through her belief; 'or rather, the arrangement ended' is more precise—it names what definitively ceased (the reciprocal relationship) without making a claim about the god's ontological status. The distinction preserves the grandmother's practice from being dismissed while honestly accounting for what ended.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
The speaker's final lines ('I still buy sugar cane / I don't know what I'm doing') indicate ongoing uncertainty rather than secured secular perspective.
C
The correction is precise and controlled rather than confused; grief may be present but the rhetorical move is philosophical, not disoriented.
D
The correction does not insist the kitchen god is not real; it carefully avoids that claim by focusing on the arrangement rather than on the god's existence.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.