Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Psychoanalytic reading

Psychoanalytic reading appears in 8 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Psychoanalytic reading is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following excerpt with a psychoanalytic dimension: For forty years Mr. Glendinning had stored his father's tools in the garage without using them. He had not thrown them away, and he had not used them, and this arrangement seemed, to himself, perfectly reasonable. When his daughter asked why he kept things he never touched, he said: 'They might come in useful.' She noticed that they were carefully oiled. She did not say what she thought. He did not say what he knew. The tools were his relationship with his father's hands, and he had preferred, for forty years, the relationship to what the hands had been. The detail that the tools are 'carefully oiled' is most significant because it:
  1. ASuggests he keeps the tools oiled so they will remain functional for the eventual practical use he insists he is saving them for.
  2. BContradicts his stated rationale ('They might come in useful') and marks the tools as objects of emotional investment rather than utility.Correct
  3. CDemonstrates that Mr. Glendinning has unconsciously inherited and faithfully reproduced his father's disciplined habits of tool maintenance.
  4. DProvides evidence that the garage functions as an orderly, well-kept space that outwardly reflects Mr. Glendinning's meticulous personality and tidy habits.

Why B is right

Mr. Glendinning says the tools are kept for potential practical use — but carefully oiling tools one never uses is not maintenance for utility; it is an act of emotional preservation. The oiling is tenderness directed at objects that represent the absent father. The narrator confirms this interpretation in the final sentence: the tools are the relationship. The detail exposes the gap between his stated and actual relationship to the tools.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Careful oiling only appears to serve his stated utility rationale; the passage stresses the tools are never used, so this is not genuine maintenance for future function.
C
The passage focuses on his emotional relationship to the tools, not the unconscious transmission of his father's habits.
D
The passage's interest is emotional, not spatial; the garage's tidiness is not what the oiling signifies.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.