Read the following passage carefully before choosing your answer.
The river had opinions. That was the only way Nkechi could explain it to the missionaries who had come to build their school on its eastern bank. She did not mean that the river spoke, exactly, though there were mornings when the sound of its current over the rocks arranged itself into something that was not quite language but was not quite not-language either. She meant that the river chose: it chose when to flood and when to recede, which canoes to carry safely and which to overturn, which children's fevers to cool when their mothers brought them to its shallows. The missionaries wrote this down in their notebooks under the heading 'Local Superstitions,' and Nkechi let them, because she understood that their notebooks were a kind of river too—a current that carried certain ideas forward and let others sink.
Nkechi's comparison of the missionaries' notebooks to a river in the final sentence most effectively accomplishes which of the following?
- AIt signals Nkechi's quiet admiration for the permanence and precision of the missionaries' written records
- BIt reveals Nkechi's hope of reconciling her people's indigenous beliefs with the missionaries' Christianity
- CIt subverts the missionaries' authority by applying the framework they dismiss to their own practicesCorrect
- DIt illustrates how oral traditions inevitably lose meaning when forced into the fixed form of written language
Why C is right
By comparing the missionaries' notebooks to a river that 'carried certain ideas forward and let others sink,' Nkechi applies the same animistic framework the missionaries have just dismissed as 'Local Superstitions' to their own tools. This inversion undermines their authority: their notebooks, like the river, choose what to preserve and what to discard, making them no more objective than the river they refuse to credit with agency.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the comparison is subversive rather than admiring; Nkechi challenges the notebooks' objectivity instead of praising their permanence or precision.
- B
- Incorrect because Nkechi does not seek to reconcile or merge the two belief systems; she reframes the missionaries' tools within her own cosmology.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage concerns the selectivity of what recording preserves, not any loss of meaning in translating oral tradition into written form.