Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Nature writing

Nature writing appears in 3 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Nature writing is tested

Example 1Harder
Read the following passage, then answer the question. From a contemporary nature writing passage with literary qualities: "I have been watching a pair of ravens for three weeks. They have a system I do not fully understand but can partially describe: one calls, the other answers with a sound I can only translate as 'acknowledged.' They do this before each flight, each landing, each change of perch. Scientists call this contact calling—a mechanism for maintaining pair bond over distance. I call it conversation. I know scientists would correct me. I accept their correction and maintain my word. There is a difference between what the mechanism is and what it means, and I am interested in meaning. The ravens may not be. This is the asymmetry I live with. I watch them; they do not watch me. Or if they do, they have not said 'acknowledged.'" The narrator's decision to use the word 'conversation' despite scientific correction most directly reflects which tension in the passage?
  1. AThe tension between scientific description (mechanism) and humanistic interpretation (meaning), which the narrator holds open without resolvingCorrect
  2. BA critique of scientific reductionism, arguing that behavioral observation alone can never capture the animal consciousness the narrator believes she perceives
  3. CThe narrator's anthropomorphism, presented as an indulgent projection that fails to respect the ravens' independence from human meaning-making
  4. DThe tension between detached observation and emotional attachment, implying the narrator is too fond of the ravens to study their behavior reliably

Why A is right

The narrator explicitly names and accepts the scientific correction, then maintains 'conversation' anyway: 'there is a difference between what the mechanism is and what it means.' The passage holds both frameworks simultaneously—mechanism (contact calling) and meaning (conversation)—without collapsing one into the other. The narrator's position is not ignorance or anti-science; it is an explicit choice to work in the register of meaning alongside the register of mechanism. The asymmetry of observation ('I watch them; they do not watch me') is accepted, not resolved.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
The passage does not argue against scientific description; it argues for a coexistence of registers, not the inadequacy of science.
C
The passage does not present the narrator's anthropomorphism critically; the narrator is self-aware and positions the word 'conversation' as a deliberate interpretive choice, not an unreflective projection.
D
Emotional investment is not shown to compromise observation reliability; the narrator's watching is careful and sustained, and the personal interest is explicitly disclosed and examined.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.