Read the following passage carefully before choosing your answer.
The twins' mother dressed them identically until they were nine, at which point Esme refused. Her refusal took the form not of an argument but of an action: she put on her brother's clothes and stood before her mother in pants and a button-down shirt, her hair tucked into a cap, looking so much like Felix that their mother experienced a moment of vertigo—the world's categories briefly destabilized by a girl who had decided that the most effective way to argue against being made identical was to become, temporarily, someone else. 'If I can be Felix,' Esme said, 'then Felix can be me, and if we can be each other, then dressing us the same doesn't make us the same—it makes us interchangeable, and interchangeable is not the same as same.' Their mother, who had not expected a nine-year-old to understand the difference between identity and interchangeability, unpacked that sentence for the rest of the afternoon.
Esme's argument distinguishes between 'same' and 'interchangeable' in order to
- Aexpress a wish to be a boy, treating her use of Felix's clothing as a statement about gender rather than identity
- Bshow that she reasons about questions of identity more capably than either her brother or her mother
- Cassert her individuality by showing that matching dress makes the twins interchangeable, not truly identicalCorrect
- Dprotest Felix's willingness to cooperate with their mother's insistence that the twins dress alike
Why C is right
Esme's argument is precise: identical dressing makes the twins 'interchangeable'—able to substitute for each other—rather than 'the same'—sharing an identity. By becoming Felix, she proves that identical presentation erases individuality rather than expressing twinship. Her demand is for individual recognition: she wants to be dressed as Esme, not as 'one of the twins,' because sameness of appearance produces interchangeability, not identity.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Esme dresses as Felix strategically to make a philosophical point about identity, not to express a gender preference; the cross-dressing is argumentative, not aspirational.
- B
- Incorrect because Esme's aim is individual recognition, not to prove herself smarter; the passage frames her reasoning as self-advocacy rather than intellectual competition.
- D
- Incorrect because Felix is not the target of Esme's action; she addresses her mother and her mother's practice, not her brother's compliance.