Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Implication

Implication appears in 4 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Implication is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following excerpt employing periodic sentences: After thirty years of marriage, after the move to the smaller house, after the children had gone and the dog had died and the garden had been reduced to a single bed of perennials that required less maintenance than either of them cared to admit, after all of it — they were still there, at the kitchen table, reading different sections of the same newspaper, and that was enough. The phrase 'required less maintenance than either of them cared to admit' is best understood as:
  1. AA straightforward horticultural note, since established perennial beds genuinely require far less tending than annual flowers or vegetable plots do.
  2. BGentle dark humor: the garden's diminished demands obliquely acknowledge the couple's own aging, a decline that neither of them wishes to name directly.Correct
  3. CAn ironic jab implying that the couple has grown complacent and idle in the easy comfort of their retirement years.
  4. DA foreshadowing device hinting that the neglected garden will later reignite an old quarrel between the two of them.

Why B is right

The phrase operates on two levels simultaneously: the garden literally requires less maintenance (perennials are low-maintenance), and neither of them wants to admit why — because reduced maintenance is correlated with reduced capacity. The aside acknowledges aging obliquely through the garden, which is a darker form of humor: what neither of them 'cares to admit' is not the garden's needs but their own.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
The literal reading is present but insufficient; the phrase's real work is the dark implication about the couple, not a fact about perennials.
C
The passage presents the couple with sympathy, not criticism; the reduction is age-related, not a moral failing of laziness.
D
The garden appears as a diminished element in a list of quiet losses; no future conflict is set up or foreshadowed.
Example 2Medium
Read the following dramatic excerpt and answer the question. Setting: A living room, evening. HELEN stands near the window. DAVID sits in an armchair, reading a newspaper he is not actually reading. HELEN: The Petersons are selling their house. DAVID: (not looking up) Are they. HELEN: Three bedrooms. A garden. Susan says the magnolia tree bloomed beautifully last spring. DAVID: We don't need three bedrooms. HELEN: We might. Someday. (A long pause. DAVID turns a page.) DAVID: The Hendersons' boy got into law school. HELEN: (quietly) Good for the Hendersons. (She draws the curtain closed.) The subtext of this exchange most strongly suggests that Helen and David are avoiding a direct conversation about which of the following?
  1. ATheir financial inability to purchase a new home
  2. BTheir mutual desire to relocate to a different neighborhood
  3. CTheir unresolved feelings about whether to have children togetherCorrect
  4. DTheir differing opinions about the Peterson family

Why C is right

Helen's emphasis on three bedrooms and her suggestive 'We might. Someday' implies a desire for children, while David's deflection ('We don't need three bedrooms') and shift to another family's child suggest avoidance of the topic. Helen's quiet, pained response and the gesture of closing the curtain reinforce unspoken tension about parenthood.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because neither character mentions money or affordability; David's objection is about need, not cost.
B
Incorrect because Helen's interest is in the specific features of the house that suggest family life, not in the neighborhood.
D
Incorrect because the Petersons are merely the vehicle for the subtext, not the subject of any disagreement.
Example 3Harder
Read the following passage, then answer the question. From a Renaissance drama: "CARDINAL: You ask forgiveness? Forgiveness for what, precisely? COUNT: For what you know. CARDINAL: I know a great deal. You must be specific. COUNT: You are enjoying this. CARDINAL: I am performing my office. COUNT: They are the same thing, for you. CARDINAL: (smiles) Now that is interesting. The man who has come to confess accuses me of finding pleasure in confession. Consider the implications. COUNT: I do. They do not flatter either of us." The Count's final line—'They do not flatter either of us'—achieves which effect?
  1. AAnagnorisis: the Count reaches a sudden recognition about his own moral condition, provoked into that self-knowledge by the Cardinal's needling
  2. BAnticlimax: the scene's philosophical intensity deflates into an admission of mutual culpability too general and diffuse to carry any real weight
  3. CCatharsis: the Count's admission releases the scene's accumulated emotional tension by completing his long-deferred confession
  4. DDramatic irony collapsed: both characters now share the implication, closing the knowledge gap that gave the Cardinal his advantageCorrect

Why D is right

The Cardinal has held interpretive advantage throughout—enjoying the Count's discomfort, forcing precision, observing the implications. When the Cardinal points out the implication of the accusation, he expects the Count to be trapped. The Count's response—'They do not flatter either of us'—accepts the implication fully and extends it to the Cardinal. The act of extending equalizes them: both are implicated, both are known. The knowledge gap that gave the Cardinal his power is collapsed by the Count's willingness to share it.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Anagnorisis is a sudden recognition; the Count's response suggests he has long known the implication ('I do') rather than discovering it for the first time.
B
The admission is not anticlimactic—it is a precise and pointed equalization of two figures. 'Does not flatter either of us' is specific in implication, not vague.
C
No confession has been made; the exchange is a deferral of confession, not its completion—catharsis requires completed release, not ongoing deferral.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.