Read the following poem carefully before choosing your answer.
Practice
The monks who rake the gravel garden
know the pattern will not last.
The wind will come.
The rain will come.
The leaves will fall
from the maple
they have chosen
not to cut down.
They rake anyway.
Not despite the impermanence
but because of it.
The practice is not
in the pattern
but in the raking,
not in the result
but in the hand
that holds the rake
and draws the line
and lets it go.
The poem's assertion that the practice "is not in the pattern but in the raking" most directly argues that
- Athe monks should cut down the maple tree so its falling leaves cannot disturb the raked pattern
- Bphysical labor holds greater spiritual worth than the intellectual contemplation associated with meditation
- Cthe Zen gravel garden is aesthetically inferior to gardens designed for lasting visual permanence
- Dmeaning resides in the process of engaged action rather than in the permanence of whatever that action producesCorrect
Why D is right
The poem separates the practice from its result: the monks rake knowing the pattern will be destroyed by wind, rain, and leaves. They rake 'not despite the impermanence but because of it.' The practice -- the meaning -- is 'in the raking' (the process of engagement) rather than 'in the pattern' (the product). The poem argues that value lies in engaged action itself, not in the durability of what the action produces.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the monks have 'chosen not to cut down' the maple; the falling leaves are part of the impermanence they accept, and that acceptance is precisely what gives the raking its meaning.
- B
- Incorrect because the poem does not rank physical labor above contemplation; raking is presented as a contemplative practice that integrates body and mind, not as mere labor opposed to thought.
- C
- Incorrect because the poem presents the gravel garden with reverence, not as inferior; the garden is the vehicle for a meditation on process and impermanence, not a judgment about relative beauty.