Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Imperfection

Imperfection appears in 4 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Imperfection is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following poem carefully before choosing your answer. The Mender She sits by the window with needle and thread and mends what the world has torn: a hem that caught on a nail, a seam that split under weight, a buttonhole stretched past use by a hand too eager to leave. She does not make new things. She returns old things to service— not to their original state (that is impossible and she knows it) but to a state of continued use, which is not perfection but is, she believes, something better: perfection with a history. The mender's distinction between 'perfection' and 'perfection with a history' most directly expresses
  1. Athe practical argument that mending worn garments costs far less than replacing them, so thrift should outweigh the appeal of buying new
  2. Ba nostalgic preference for antique furniture and vintage clothing whose visible age makes them more beautiful than anything newly manufactured
  3. Cthe idea that a restored object keeps its function while bearing evidence of its survival, making it richer than something merely newCorrect
  4. Dthe mender's quiet frustration that modern garments are so poorly constructed that they tear far sooner than older, sturdier ones once did

Why C is right

The mender returns objects not to 'their original state' but to 'a state of continued use'—'not perfection but perfection with a history.' This distinction means the repaired object carries two things: its function (restored) and its history (visible in the mend). The mender considers this 'something better' than perfection—an object that works and also shows evidence of having been torn and restored, making it richer than something merely new and flawless.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the mender's motivation is philosophical ('she believes'), not economic; the value she describes is conceptual (perfection with a history), not a matter of cost or thrift.
B
Incorrect because the mender's philosophy applies to everyday garments kept in active use, not to collectible antiques or vintage fashion; the value lies in continued service, not in aesthetic or nostalgic appeal.
D
Incorrect because the mender expresses no frustration and does not criticize how the garments were made; she accepts the tearing as given and focuses on the value the repair confers.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.