Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Control

Control appears in 3 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Control is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage carefully before choosing your answer. The morning after her mother's funeral, Clara found herself reorganizing the pantry. She removed every can and jar, wiped each shelf with a damp cloth, and replaced the items in alphabetical order -- something her mother would have found absurd. Her mother had organized by frequency of use: the flour and sugar at eye level, the rarely touched tins of smoked oysters on the highest shelf, a system that prioritized the body's habits over the mind's categories. Clara understood that what she was doing was not cleaning but arguing -- conducting a posthumous debate about how a kitchen should be ordered, which was really a debate about how a life should be ordered, and winning this argument brought her no satisfaction, only the particular loneliness of being right in an empty room. The narrator's description of Clara's reorganization of the pantry primarily serves to
  1. Aillustrate Clara's practical need to impose order and cleanliness after a period of household neglect
  2. Bestablish Clara's deep resentment toward her mother's habitual domestic philosophy and daily routines
  3. Cdemonstrate Clara's superior organizational skills over her mother's less rational domestic system
  4. Dreveal how Clara processes grief by asserting control in an unresolvable argument with her motherCorrect

Why D is right

The narrator explicitly states that Clara's reorganizing 'was not cleaning but arguing -- conducting a posthumous debate.' Imposing alphabetical order over her mother's system is an attempt to assert control during grief, while the 'particular loneliness of being right in an empty room' reveals the argument cannot be resolved because her interlocutor is gone. The reorganization is thus a mechanism for processing loss through a symbolic, one-sided conversation, which choice D captures.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the narrator explicitly states the activity 'was not cleaning but arguing,' undermining a purely practical reading; there is also no indication the pantry had been neglected.
B
Incorrect because the passage conveys grief and loneliness rather than resentment; Clara's empty victory suggests she misses the presence that would make the debate meaningful, not that she harbors anger toward her mother's routines.
C
Incorrect because the passage does not frame either system as superior; the mother's organization 'prioritized the body's habits,' a valid logic, and Clara's victory brings 'no satisfaction,' so no rational superiority is asserted.
Example 2Harder
Read the following passage carefully before choosing your answer. It was Aunt Harriet's custom to arrive two hours early to every family event and spend those hours rearranging whatever the host had already arranged. She moved centerpieces, refolded napkins, adjusted chairs by degrees so subtle that no one could point to a specific change but everyone felt, upon entering, that the room was somehow more Harriet than it had been before. She did not do this to be controlling, or not only to be controlling; she did it because she believed, with the conviction of a woman who had survived two husbands and a flood, that the world was a fundamentally disordered place and that her job -- perhaps anyone's job, but certainly hers -- was to impose upon it a structure it would not choose for itself. That the structure she imposed was always her own, and that she could not conceive of order that did not look like her order, was a limitation she had never been invited to examine. The final clause -- "a limitation she had never been invited to examine" -- most directly suggests that
  1. AHarriet simply lacks the intelligence needed to recognize the self-contradiction at the heart of her compulsive rearranging
  2. Bthe family's tolerance has prevented Harriet from confronting the self-serving nature of her compulsion to impose orderCorrect
  3. CHarriet's relatives have deliberately withheld their criticism in order to spare her feelings and preserve a fragile family peace
  4. DHarriet's social isolation has left her without the friends who might otherwise have challenged her rigid assumptions about order

Why B is right

The phrase 'never been invited to examine' implies that no one -- neither family nor circumstance -- has prompted Harriet to scrutinize her assumption that her personal sense of order is universal. The family's passive acceptance ('no one could point to a specific change') has created an environment where Harriet's limitation -- equating her order with order itself -- has never been challenged. The wording suggests that the examination is available but uninitiated, with the family's tolerance functioning as an enabler.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the passage attributes the limitation to a lack of external challenge, not to intellectual incapacity; Harriet holds a coherent 'conviction' about disorder that is simply unexamined, not beyond her comprehension.
C
Incorrect because 'never been invited to examine' does not specify deliberate withholding; it points to the absence of any prompt to reflect, which could stem from tolerance, avoidance, or indifference rather than protective intent.
D
Incorrect because the passage situates Harriet at family events where she interacts with others; her limitation arises not from isolation but from the fact that no one in her social world has prompted self-reflection.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.