Read the following passage, then answer the question.
From an 18th-century mock-heroic poem:
"Now mighty Beldame, empress of the queue,
Who rules the baker's line with iron will,
Advanced her elbow—weapon tried and true—
And seized the final loaf, against all skill
Of those who'd risen early, cold and pale,
To stand three hours in frost for daily bread.
The Muse must sing of this heroic tale,
Of conquest bright and rivals' hopes struck dead.
For what are Troy's high walls to this great siege?
What Agamemnon's rage to Beldame's scowl?
The epic catalogue of her liege
Includes one purse, one bonnet, and one jowl."
The phrase 'one purse, one bonnet, and one jowl' at the poem's conclusion best exemplifies which device?
- ABathos, as the elevated mock-heroic register deflates into a mundane domestic inventoryCorrect
- BOxymoron, as pairing physical objects with a financial item yokes mutually contradictory terms together
- CZeugma, as one implied verb governs several nouns that each belong to a different semantic register
- DPeripeteia, as the heroine's fortunes reverse suddenly at the poem's climactic and decisive final line
Why A is right
Bathos is the deliberate descent from the elevated to the trivial or absurd. The poem has sustained mock-heroic grandeur—invoking Troy, Agamemnon, the Muse—and the closing 'catalogue' of the heroine's 'liege' reduces to three comic domestic items: a purse, a bonnet, and a jowl. This bathetic drop is the joke the poem has been building toward.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Oxymoron joins two contradictory terms in a compressed phrase; a list of three unlike nouns is not oxymoronic—there is only comic incongruity, no logical contradiction between the items.
- C
- Zeugma requires one word to govern others in genuinely different senses; the verb 'includes' applies in the same plain sense to all three nouns, so despite their differing registers no zeugma occurs.
- D
- Peripeteia is a sudden reversal of fortune in a narrative; the Beldame does not lose what she has gained, and the closing line is a descriptive catalogue, not a plot reversal.
Read the following excerpt from a literary satire featuring a static character:
Professor Aldous had held the same opinion about the direction of Western civilization for thirty-seven years. He had arrived at it in graduate school — 'irreversible decline' — and had been collecting evidence ever since. Every new development confirmed what he already knew. The internet confirmed it. The fall of the Soviet Union confirmed it. A student's incorrect use of 'whom' confirmed it. He was not closed-minded; he simply had the advantage of having been correct for so long that new hypotheses seemed indecent.
The list 'The internet confirmed it. The fall of the Soviet Union confirmed it. A student's incorrect use of 'whom' confirmed it.' achieves its satirical effect primarily through:
- AAnaphora; the repeated 'confirmed it' builds an incantatory, persuasive rhythm that lends Professor Aldous's position genuine cumulative authority.
- BHyperbole; the overstated claim that a single grammar slip proves civilizational decline is offered in complete, unironic earnestness.
- CParallelism; the matched grammatical form of the three clauses gives them a balanced, intellectually credible symmetry.
- DBathos; the descent from world-historical events to a trivial grammar error deflates his grand thesis for comic effect.Correct
Why D is right
Bathos is the rhetorical descent from the elevated to the trivial. The list begins with significant historical phenomena (the internet, the fall of the Soviet Union) and concludes with a student's grammatical error. The sudden drop in scale is comic precisely because Professor Aldous treats all three as equally weighty evidence of civilizational collapse. The bathetic structure exposes his inability to calibrate significance.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- While anaphora is present ('confirmed it'), the effect is not persuasive but satirical — the repetition accumulates to absurdity, not authority.
- B
- The passage is presented as ironic rather than earnest; the satire depends on the reader recognizing the disproportion.
- C
- Parallel structure is present, but the primary satirical device is the bathetic descent, which the parallelism makes more conspicuous.
Read the following passage.
The trial lasted eleven days and produced a verdict that satisfied no one, which is—according to the judge, who had been doing this for thirty-seven years—the hallmark of justice. The defendant was found guilty of a crime that had, in the interim between commission and conviction, been reclassified from a felony to a misdemeanor, which meant that the full weight of the law had been brought to bear on an act that the law no longer considered worth the bearing. The sentence was time served. The defendant had served three years awaiting trial for what now amounted to, legally speaking, a parking violation with consequences.
This is the architecture of the justice system: a cathedral built to scale, staffed by sincere people, maintained at enormous expense, and occasionally—just occasionally—producing the ecclesiastical equivalent of a shrug.
The concluding metaphor comparing the justice system to a cathedral that produces 'a shrug' employs bathos to suggest that
- Athe defendant, who had already spent three years in jail awaiting trial, deserved a far harsher final sentence than time served
- Bthe judge, despite his thirty-seven years on the bench, is incompetent and personally to blame for the miscarriage of justice
- Cthe vast and costly institutional apparatus of justice can produce outcomes so trivial that the system inadvertently satirizes itselfCorrect
- Dcathedrals are overvalued as architectural achievements, and society misplaces its reverence for grand monumental structures
Why C is right
The bathos lies in the contrast between the cathedral (massive, sincere, expensive) and its output (a shrug—an expression of indifference or helplessness). By comparing the justice system to a grand structure that produces nothing proportionate to its scale, the passage suggests that institutional grandeur can culminate in absurd inadequacy. The system does not fail through malice but through the bathetic mismatch between its apparatus and its results.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage's irony concerns the crime being reclassified mid-trial, not the leniency of the sentence; the point is institutional absurdity, not insufficient punishment.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage presents the judge as experienced and philosophical ('thirty-seven years'), not incompetent; the system's failure is structural, not individual.
- D
- Incorrect because the cathedral metaphor targets the justice system, not literal cathedrals; the passage uses the cathedral's grandeur as a vehicle for critique, not as the object of critique.