Read the following passage and answer the question.
Silicon Valley's relationship with privacy can be summarized in a single corporate mantra: 'Move fast and break things.' The 'things' that got broken, it turns out, included the Fourth Amendment's spirit, the informed consent of two billion users, and the quaint notion that a person's medical searches, political affiliations, and romantic interests are nobody else's business. But the mantra was never really about speed. It was about permission — a self-granted license to disrupt social norms and legal frameworks in the name of innovation, and to apologize later, if at all, from behind a wall of legal immunity and shareholder returns.
The author's use of the phrase 'quaint notion' to describe personal privacy is an example of
- Aa precise legal definition of privacy borrowed directly from Fourth Amendment case law
- Bverbal irony: dismissive wording that actually reinforces privacy's continuing importanceCorrect
- Ca candid concession that evolving technology has made privacy expectations genuinely obsolete
- Dgenuine nostalgia for a bygone era when privacy protections were stronger and more respected
Why B is right
The phrase 'quaint notion' is verbal irony: the author does not actually believe privacy is quaint or outdated. By adopting the dismissive language that tech companies might use, the author highlights the industry's cavalier attitude while simultaneously insisting on privacy's enduring significance.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because 'quaint notion' is a rhetorical, ironic word choice, not a legal or technical definition drawn from case law.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage's critical tone makes clear the author views privacy as important, not genuinely obsolete; the dismissive phrasing is adopted ironically, not sincerely conceded.
- D
- Incorrect because the phrase is used ironically, not with genuine nostalgia; the author's tone toward the industry is critical rather than wistful.