Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The river has no opinion about the dam. It does not resent the concrete that redirects its current or mourn the canyon it once carved. It adjusts. Water finds the path of least resistance not because it chooses to but because it has no mechanism for choosing otherwise. This is worth remembering when we invoke nature to justify human arrangements. 'It's only natural,' we say when we mean 'It's only convenient.' Natural selection is invoked to justify economic competition. The food chain is invoked to justify social hierarchy. The river's indifference to the dam is invoked to justify adaptation to injustice. But nature does not justify. It merely describes. The river that flows around the dam is not endorsing the dam. It is obeying physics. When we confuse physical necessity with moral endorsement, we commit the naturalistic fallacy — the error of deriving what ought to be from what is. The river cannot choose. We can. That difference is the beginning and end of ethics.
The passage moves from a description of a river's behavior to a philosophical argument about ethics. This structural movement from concrete image to abstract principle serves to
- Aground the abstract naturalistic-fallacy concept in a vivid, concrete image before the philosophical claim is stated explicitlyCorrect
- Bargue that rivers and other natural waterways should be legally protected from dam construction on environmental grounds
- Cdemonstrate that the author possesses specialized expertise in both hydrology and academic philosophy
- Dsuggest that human behavior is as fully determined by physical forces as a river's course, leaving no room for moral choice
Why A is right
The passage begins with a concrete, easily visualized image (a river flowing around a dam) and uses it to build toward the abstract philosophical concept (the naturalistic fallacy). By the time the reader reaches the philosophical claim, the river example has already made the concept intuitive: just as the river's behavior around the dam is physics, not endorsement, nature's patterns are descriptions, not prescriptions.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the passage uses the river as a philosophical illustration, not as the subject of an environmental argument; the dam is a metaphorical device, not the topic of the passage.
- C
- Incorrect because the river description and philosophical analysis serve a unified argumentative purpose; they are not separate demonstrations of expertise in two fields.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage's conclusion explicitly asserts the opposite: 'The river cannot choose. We can.' The argument distinguishes human moral agency from physical determinism.