Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The poet and essayist Adrienne Rich, writing in the 1970s and 1980s, developed a prose style that refused the conventional academic divide between argument and experience. Her essays — collected in 'On Lies, Secrets, and Silence' and 'Blood, Bread, and Poetry' — move fluidly between personal testimony and political theory, between memory and analysis. A sentence about her own body might transition directly into a sentence about institutional power. The effect is not confusion but insistence: that the personal and the political are not separate domains, and that writing which pretends otherwise is already making a political choice. Rich's critics found this difficult to engage on purely analytical grounds because the form itself was an argument — her refusal to separate subject from object, experience from theory, was not a failure of rigor but its own kind of precision.
The author's claim that Rich's 'form itself was an argument' primarily suggests that...
- ARich's blending of personal testimony and political theory within her sentences enacted the very claim she was making about their inseparabilityCorrect
- Bcritics who struggled with Rich's essays were unable to appreciate the literary quality and emotional honesty of her prose
- CRich's writing style was influenced primarily by poetic conventions rather than by argumentative or scholarly traditions
- DRich's essays lack the formal structure and logical organization necessary to support sustained analytical engagement with her ideas
Why A is right
The passage explains that Rich's refusal to separate personal experience from political theory was not merely a stylistic choice but a demonstration of her central claim: that they are inseparable. The form enacts the argument — it doesn't just state it.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- The criticism the author mentions is about analytical engagement with the form, not about literary or emotional appreciation.
- C
- The passage attributes the style to a deliberate argumentative choice, not to poetic convention.
- D
- The author explicitly states that the integration is 'not a failure of rigor but its own kind of precision' — it is rigorous and structured, not lacking in organization.