Read the following passage and answer the question.
A prominent tech executive's declaration — 'The age of privacy is over' — was not a description of reality but a prescription for it. It was the kind of statement that, by being spoken from a position of sufficient power, helps bring about the condition it describes. When the head of a dominant social network declares that privacy is dead, he is not reporting on social norms; he is attempting to reshape them. The declaration serves his company's interests: a world without privacy expectations is a world in which the company's data practices face no friction. This is what linguists call a 'performative utterance' — a statement that does not merely describe the world but acts upon it, like a judge pronouncing a sentence or a priest declaring a marriage.
The author's identification of the executive's statement as a 'performative utterance' reveals which attitude toward the statement?
- AAgreement that privacy norms have already shifted in the direction the executive described
- BAcademic admiration for the executive's rhetorical skill in blurring description and prescription to shape public perception
- CSuspicion that the statement was designed to normalize conditions favorable to the companyCorrect
- DIndifference to whether the executive's statement functioned as description or as prescription for future norms
Why C is right
By identifying the statement as performative rather than descriptive, the author exposes its strategic function: the executive was not reporting on reality but attempting to construct a reality favorable to the company's interests. The analysis reveals suspicion of the statement's corporate motivations, not admiration for its craft or indifference to its purpose.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the author characterizes the statement as prescriptive, not as an accurate description of existing norms.
- B
- Incorrect because the analysis is critical, exposing the statement's self-serving function rather than admiring its rhetorical skill in blurring description and prescription.
- D
- Incorrect because the entire passage distinguishes description from prescription, demonstrating the opposite of indifference to the statement's function.