Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The architectural theorist Robert Venturi famously responded to Mies van der Rohe's dictum 'Less is more' with 'Less is a bore.' The aphorism was not merely contrarian. Venturi was mounting a substantive argument about the relationship between architecture and human experience. A building that has been stripped of ornament, historical reference, and programmatic complexity does not achieve purity — it achieves impoverishment. Human beings do not inhabit abstractions; they inhabit places that accumulate meaning through detail, association, and memory. The International Style's rejection of ornament was, in Venturi's view, not an aesthetic choice but an ideological one — an imposition of elite modernist values on users who had never been asked what they wanted. His 1966 book 'Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture' made the case for ambiguity as a virtue, for buildings that could hold multiple meanings simultaneously, and for an architecture that acknowledged the messiness of actual human life.
Venturi's restatement of Mies's dictum as 'Less is a bore' primarily functions as...
- Aa concession to critics of modernism who preferred traditional ornamental styles of design
- Ban appeal to popular taste that undermines the intellectual credibility of Venturi's broader argument
- Ca rhetorical inversion signaling a deeper philosophical disagreement about architecture and human experienceCorrect
- Da dismissive personal attack on Mies van der Rohe that lacks any substantive architectural or theoretical argument
Why C is right
The author clarifies that the aphorism 'was not merely contrarian' — it announced a substantive disagreement about whether stripped-down architecture enriches or impoverishes human experience. As the passage's opening move, the inversion sets up and signals the deeper philosophical dispute that the rest of the passage develops — an organizational/structural function rather than a claim about audience or a stand-alone piece of evidence.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage frames Venturi's argument as philosophical and humanistic, not as a concession to traditionalist aesthetic preferences.
- B
- The passage presents the aphorism as the opening of a serious theoretical argument, not as a populist move that undermines his credibility.
- D
- The passage explicitly states the aphorism was 'not merely contrarian' and proceeds to explain the substantive argument behind it.