Let . Which of the following correctly describes the behavior of near and ?
- AVertical asymptotes at both and
- BA hole at and a vertical asymptote at Correct
- CA vertical asymptote at and a hole at
- DHoles at both and
Why B is right
Factor: . The factor cancels, creating a hole at with . The factor does not cancel, so is a vertical asymptote. The result follows from simplifying the expression, using continuity, or applying the stated limit law. The raw indeterminate form is only a starting point; the simplified expression determines the answer.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Students identify zeros of the denominator without checking whether those factors cancel. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.
- C
- Students reverse which value gives a hole vs. asymptote. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.
- D
- Students think any shared factor creates a hole, without checking that is not in the numerator. This distractor comes from stopping at the unsimplified form or using the raw result as if it were the answer. The correct limit is found after the algebra is cleaned up.