A student examines two cell types under an electron microscope. Cell A has abundant mitochondria, extensive rough ER, and a prominent Golgi apparatus. Cell B has few mitochondria, abundant smooth ER, and many peroxisomes. Which of the following is the most reasonable inference about the functions of these cells?
- ABoth cells perform the same specialized function but are at different stages of the cell cycle
- BCell A is a prokaryotic cell and Cell B is a eukaryotic cell, based on their organelles
- CCell A is specialized for lipid synthesis and detoxification; Cell B for secreting proteins
- DCell A is specialized for protein secretion; Cell B for lipid metabolism and detoxificationCorrect
Why D is right
Cell A's abundant mitochondria (for energy), extensive rough ER (for protein synthesis and processing), and prominent Golgi apparatus (for protein modification and sorting) indicate specialization for protein secretion — characteristic of cells like pancreatic acinar cells. Cell B's abundant smooth ER (for lipid synthesis, steroid production, detoxification) and peroxisomes (for fatty acid oxidation, detoxification of harmful substances) indicate specialization for lipid metabolism and detoxification — characteristic of liver hepatocytes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the distinct organelle compositions suggest different functional specializations, not different cell cycle stages. Cell cycle stages affect nuclear appearance and chromosome condensation, not the relative abundance of ER types and peroxisomes.
- B
- Incorrect because both cells have membrane-bound organelles (ER, Golgi, mitochondria, peroxisomes), which are hallmarks of eukaryotic cells. Prokaryotic cells lack these organelles.
- C
- Incorrect because this reverses the functions of the two cells. Rough ER and Golgi are associated with protein secretion (Cell A), while smooth ER and peroxisomes are associated with lipid metabolism and detoxification (Cell B).