A red blood cell is placed in a 0.9% NaCl solution (isotonic) and maintains its normal biconcave shape. If the same cell is transferred to a 0.2% NaCl solution, which of the following would occur?
- AThe cell would swell and lyse as water enters by osmosisCorrect
- BThe cell would actively pump out excess water to maintain its biconcave shape
- CThe cell would crenate as water moves out by osmosis into the dilute solution
- DThe cell would remain unchanged because NaCl concentration does not affect cell volume
Why A is right
A 0.2% NaCl solution is hypotonic relative to the red blood cell's cytoplasm. Water moves into the cell by osmosis from the region of higher water potential (dilute solution) to lower water potential (more concentrated cytoplasm). Since red blood cells lack a cell wall, the influx of water causes the cell to swell and eventually burst (lyse), a process called hemolysis.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because red blood cells cannot actively pump out water fast enough to prevent lysis in a significantly hypotonic solution. While cells have some volume regulatory mechanisms, the osmotic gradient in 0.2% NaCl overwhelms these defenses.
- C
- Incorrect because crenation (shrinkage with a spiky appearance) occurs in hypertonic solutions where water leaves the cell. In a dilute (hypotonic) solution, water enters the cell rather than leaving it.
- D
- Incorrect because NaCl concentration directly affects the osmolarity of the solution relative to the cell. A change from isotonic (0.9%) to hypotonic (0.2%) creates an osmotic gradient that drives water into the cell.
An experiment tests the effect of various solute concentrations on red blood cell volume. The following data are collected:
| NaCl Concentration (%) | Cell Appearance |
|------------------------|------------------|
| 0.1 | Swollen, some lysed |
| 0.5 | Slightly swollen |
| 0.9 | Normal biconcave |
| 1.5 | Crenated (shrunken) |
| 3.0 | Severely crenated |
Which NaCl concentration represents an isotonic solution for red blood cells?
- A1.5%
- B0.9%Correct
- C0.5%
- D0.1%
Why B is right
An isotonic solution has the same solute concentration (osmolarity) as the cell's cytoplasm, resulting in no net water movement and the cell maintaining its normal shape. At 0.9% NaCl, the red blood cells maintain their normal biconcave disc shape, indicating that this is the isotonic concentration. This is why 0.9% NaCl is used as normal saline in medical settings.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because at 1.5% NaCl, cells are crenated (shrunken with a spiky appearance), indicating a hypertonic solution where water leaves the cells.
- C
- Incorrect because at 0.5% NaCl, cells are slightly swollen, indicating a mildly hypotonic solution. More water enters than leaves, though not enough to cause lysis.
- D
- Incorrect because at 0.1% NaCl, cells are swollen and some have lysed, indicating a severely hypotonic solution where water enters the cells by osmosis.