A researcher tests whether a buffer can maintain pH when acid is added. They add 0.01 mol HCl to 1 L of pure water (initial pH 7) and to 1 L of phosphate buffer (pH 7, pKa ≈ 7.2). The resulting pH of water drops to approximately 2 while the buffer pH drops only to 6.8. This result demonstrates that buffers work by:
- AUsing weak acid/conjugate base pairs to accept or donate protons, resisting pH changeCorrect
- BNeutralizing all of the added acid by converting every added H+ ion into water molecules
- CRaising the pH of the solution above the acid's pKa to prevent dissociation
- DDiluting the added acid until its concentration falls below the threshold needed for ionization
Why A is right
Buffers consist of a weak acid and its conjugate base. When H+ is added, the conjugate base accepts the proton (H+ + A- → HA), consuming free H+ and preventing a large pH drop. The effectiveness is greatest when solution pH is near the pKa of the buffer pair, which is why the phosphate buffer (pKa ≈ 7.2) performs well at pH 7.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Buffers do not convert all added acid (every H+) to water; they chemically bind protons into the weak acid form, shifting equilibrium rather than eliminating H+ as water.
- C
- Buffers do not raise pH above the pKa; they maintain pH near the pKa by resisting change in both directions.
- D
- Dilution is not the mechanism; buffering occurs through chemical reactions, not by reducing the acid's concentration below some ionization threshold.