Cytochrome c is a protein involved in the electron transport chain of all aerobic organisms. The amino acid sequence of cytochrome c differs by 1 amino acid between humans and chimpanzees, 13 between humans and dogs, 20 between humans and rattlesnakes, and 44 between humans and yeast. A researcher uses these differences to construct a molecular clock. Which assumption must be valid for the molecular clock to accurately estimate divergence times?
- AAll organisms evolved from humans, so differences measure time since divergence from humans
- BCytochrome c mutations arise only during mass extinction events, when selective pressures are strongest
- CAmino acid substitutions in cytochrome c accumulate at a roughly constant rate across lineagesCorrect
- DMore closely related species always share completely identical cytochrome c sequences with one another
Why C is right
The molecular clock hypothesis assumes that neutral mutations (or amino acid substitutions) accumulate at an approximately constant rate over evolutionary time. If the rate of substitution is roughly constant, then the number of differences between two species' sequences is proportional to the time since they diverged from their common ancestor. This assumption allows calibration using known divergence times from the fossil record and extrapolation to estimate unknown divergence times.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because molecular clock analysis does not assume that all organisms evolved from humans. Differences between any two species measure time since divergence from their common ancestor, not from one species to another. Humans are not the ancestral species.
- B
- Incorrect because molecular clock analysis assumes mutations accumulate continuously over time, not that they occur only during specific events. Mass extinctions may change selective pressures and affect which lineages survive, but they do not control mutation rates.
- D
- Incorrect because closely related species typically have very similar but not necessarily identical sequences. Even closely related species accumulate some mutations in the time since their divergence. The small number of differences between humans and chimps (1 amino acid) reflects recent divergence, not identity.
The molecular clock for mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) in mammals ticks at approximately 2% sequence divergence per million years. Two species of rodents show 10% mtDNA sequence divergence. What is the estimated divergence time between these species?
- A20 million years ago
- B10 million years ago
- C5 million years agoCorrect
- D2 million years ago
Why C is right
Using the molecular clock: divergence time = percent divergence / rate of divergence per million years = 10% / 2% per million years = 5 million years ago. The 2% per million years rate already accounts for divergence on both lineages (it is a pairwise divergence rate), so no additional division by 2 is needed. This calculation estimates that the two rodent species last shared a common ancestor approximately 5 million years ago.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because 20 million years would predict 40% divergence, far more than the observed 10%. This answer may result from multiplying rather than dividing.
- B
- Incorrect because 10 million years would predict 20% divergence at 2% per million years, not the observed 10%. This answer incorrectly divides divergence by 1% rather than 2%.
- D
- Incorrect because 2 million years would only account for 4% divergence at a rate of 2% per million years, not the observed 10% divergence.