A geneticist studies a family with a rare genetic disorder affecting lysosomal enzyme targeting. Patients' cells produce normal lysosomal enzymes, but the enzymes are secreted from the cell instead of being delivered to lysosomes. Which of the following is the most likely defect?
- AA mutation in lysosomal membrane proteins that prevents enzymes from entering
- BA mutation preventing synthesis of lysosomal enzymes on the rough ER
- CAn inability of the Golgi apparatus to form any transport vesicles at all
- DA defect in mannose-6-phosphate tagging of the enzymes in the GolgiCorrect
Why D is right
Lysosomal enzymes are tagged with mannose-6-phosphate (M6P) in the Golgi apparatus. M6P receptors in the trans-Golgi network recognize these tags and direct the enzymes into vesicles destined for lysosomes. If the M6P tagging system is defective (as in I-cell disease/mucolipidosis II), enzymes are not properly sorted and instead follow the default secretory pathway, being released from the cell. The enzymes themselves are functional; they simply go to the wrong destination.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because enzymes reach lysosomes by vesicle fusion, not by crossing the lysosomal membrane. The defect is in sorting at the Golgi, not at the lysosome itself.
- B
- Incorrect because the question states that normal lysosomal enzymes are produced. The problem is not with synthesis but with sorting/targeting after production.
- C
- Incorrect because if the cell could not produce transport vesicles from the Golgi, all vesicular transport would be affected, not just lysosomal targeting. The enzymes are being secreted (via vesicles), so vesicle formation is intact.