A researcher discovers that a population of mice on a dark lava flow has evolved dark fur coloration through mutations in the Mc1r gene (which controls melanin production). A nearby population on light sand retains light fur. Both populations exchange occasional migrants. If migration increases significantly, what would be the most likely effect on the dark-furred lava flow population?
- AMigration would have no effect, because selection on the lava flow is strong enough to eliminate every incoming light-fur allele immediately
- BGene flow would bring in light-fur alleles, which could lower the frequency of the locally adaptive dark-fur alleleCorrect
- CThe light-furred sand population would shift toward dark coloration, since gene flow runs only from the lava flow into the sand population
- DThe lava flow population would become even darker, because gene flow always raises the frequency of locally adapted alleles in the recipient population
Why B is right
Increased gene flow from the light sand population would introduce Mc1r alleles for light fur into the lava flow population. These light-fur alleles would be selected against on the dark lava (predators can see light mice more easily), but if migration is strong enough, gene flow can swamp local adaptation by continuously introducing maladaptive alleles faster than selection can remove them. This migration-selection balance determines whether the lava flow population can maintain its locally adapted dark coloration.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because no natural selection is infinitely strong or instantaneous. If migration rate exceeds the strength of selection, gene flow can prevent or erode local adaptation. The outcome depends on the balance between selection intensity and migration rate.
- C
- Incorrect because gene flow is bidirectional, not one-way: light-fur alleles would also flow into the lava population. And whether dark alleles would increase on the sand depends on the balance between selection against dark fur on light sand and the amount of gene flow. It is not a given.
- D
- Incorrect because gene flow introduces alleles from the source population whether or not they are adaptive in the receiving population. Migration from a light-sand population brings light-fur alleles that are maladaptive on dark lava, not adaptive.