A biologist studying a population of land snails on a series of islands finds that snails on islands with dense vegetation have darker shells, while snails on islands with sparse, light-colored vegetation have lighter shells. The biologist hypothesizes that shell color provides camouflage from bird predators. Which of the following types of evidence would most strongly support this hypothesis?
- AA survey showing that shell color varies with average temperature and rainfall across all islands
- BGenetic crosses confirming that shell color is inherited as a single gene with dark dominant to light
- CA molecular phylogeny showing that the dark-shelled and light-shelled populations are closely related
- DA predation experiment showing that birds preferentially eat snails whose shells do not match their backgroundCorrect
Why D is right
The hypothesis proposes that shell color camouflage reduces predation by birds. The strongest evidence would be a predation experiment that directly tests whether birds preferentially eat snails whose shells do not match their background. That would establish a causal link between coloration, predation, and fitness.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because a correlation with climate (temperature and rainfall) would point to another explanation, such as thermoregulation, and would not support the camouflage hypothesis.
- B
- Incorrect because knowing how shell color is inherited does not show that the color gives a selective advantage through camouflage.
- C
- Incorrect because a phylogeny shows how the populations are related but does not explain why shell color differs between islands or show a selective advantage.