A small population of finches on an island experiences a severe drought that kills 90% of the population. The surviving 10% happen to have, on average, larger beaks than the original population. After the drought, the population recovers but now has a different average beak size. This event is most accurately described as:
- AA bottleneck effect if survival was random with respect to beak size, natural selection if larger beaks aided survival, or bothCorrect
- BDirectional natural selection alone, because larger beaks must have been what allowed individuals to survive the drought
- CStabilizing selection, because the drought removed individuals with extreme beak sizes and favored the intermediate beak phenotype
- DThe founder effect, because the few surviving birds founded a new population whose allele frequencies differ from the original
Why A is right
This scenario could involve genetic drift (bottleneck effect), natural selection, or both, depending on whether beak size provided a survival advantage during the drought. If larger beaks allowed access to harder seeds available during drought (as documented in Galapagos finches by Peter and Rosemary Grant), then natural selection favored larger beaks. If the survivors happened to have larger beaks by chance (e.g., they survived due to location rather than beak size), then this represents a bottleneck effect (genetic drift). In reality, both processes likely contributed.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because this answer assumes that larger beaks were necessarily advantageous without considering that the shift could also be due to random survival (genetic drift). Without knowing whether beak size affected survival probability during the drought, we cannot attribute the change solely to natural selection.
- C
- Incorrect because stabilizing selection would maintain the original average beak size and reduce variance. The observed shift in average beak size indicates directional change, whether caused by selection, drift, or both.
- D
- Incorrect because the founder effect specifically describes a small group colonizing a new location, not a population crash and recovery in the same location. This scenario is a bottleneck effect (if drift is involved), not a founder effect.