A researcher tests four solutions with Benedict's reagent and records the following results: Solution 1 (glucose) — brick red; Solution 2 (fructose) — brick red; Solution 3 (sucrose) — blue; Solution 4 (lactose) — brick red. Based on these results, which conclusion is best supported?
- AAll disaccharides are non-reducing sugars because their monomers are joined by a glycosidic bond
- BSucrose is non-reducing because both anomeric carbons are tied up in the glycosidic bond joining its monomersCorrect
- CFructose cannot reduce Cu2+ because it is a ketose lacking the free aldehyde group of aldoses
- DLactose is a monosaccharide, since only single sugar units give a positive Benedict's test
Why B is right
The data show that glucose (aldose), fructose (ketose), and lactose (disaccharide) all reduce Benedict's reagent, while sucrose does not. The reason sucrose is non-reducing is that its glycosidic bond links the C1 of glucose to the C2 of fructose — both anomeric carbons — leaving no free hemiacetal or hemiketal group to open and reduce Cu2+. Lactose, in contrast, has a free anomeric C1 on its glucose unit.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Lactose is a disaccharide joined by a glycosidic bond, yet it gives a positive Benedict's test, proving not all disaccharides are non-reducing; only disaccharides where both anomeric carbons are involved in the glycosidic bond are non-reducing.
- C
- Fructose is a reducing sugar despite being a ketose lacking a free aldehyde; in alkaline solution (Benedict's conditions), fructose can isomerize to an aldehyde form that can reduce Cu2+. The data confirm fructose is reducing.
- D
- A positive Benedict's test indicates reducing sugar character, not that lactose is a monosaccharide; many disaccharides are reducing, and lactose is a disaccharide (galactose + glucose) with a free anomeric carbon on the glucose unit.